Post AvVNF47Ta8qOTCFlZY by [email protected] | |
More posts by [email protected] | |
Post #AvVFLEI1snxm7HcMbo by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 2 repeats | |
Dear @creativecommons ,I read your article about your initiative for new licens… | |
Post #AvVFLERFKXKsZrviyW by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
@davidrevoy Looks like they have a wishy-washy page that speaks to some of that… | |
Post #AvVN8jS7VaqMdPtCgi by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @creativecommons from the 4 proposed signals (credit, direct contri… | |
Post #AvVN94hQVsZ6WyDDxg by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @creativecommons i might misunderstand this: Isn't this more ab… | |
Post #AvVN94no89fYqlCJuK by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@ms_zwiebel @creativecommons Unfortunately, there is no mention of a 'no AI… | |
Post #AvVN9jYebOuRFdQITo by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @creativecommons ahhh i only read the post from them not the drafts… | |
Post #AvVN9jegEzjJYKF6sC by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@ms_zwiebel @creativecommons Yes, I'm curious to see how this draft will ev… | |
Post #AvVN9qgi5qVrMeFKVc by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@ms_zwiebel In addition to what @davidrevoy said, NOAI is a problem because it&… | |
Post #AvVN9qoVcqkdkptYfI by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@Linebyline @davidrevoy uhhhhhh, i did not think about this...so we need AI tag… | |
Post #AvVN9rP1R5xTa4yiZs by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@ms_zwiebel @davidrevoy To put it a bit more pithily: It's still assault ev… | |
Post #AvVN9zmMIDNXYlxT3w by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@skobkin @davidrevoy You say that it's not how generative models work, and … | |
Post #AvVNA4cyGXqAb6bXcm by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@skobkin @davidrevoy Your reasoning relies completely on assumptions that we ne… | |
Post #AvVNA6KFx63hrdrcjQ by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@carl @davidrevoy @creativecommons this feels like"yes""ask me l… | |
Post #AvVNAs16dbGFm9H0Xw by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy I would be happy if they just said: there were always clear rules. … | |
Post #AvVNAs8YBvDS9Ekx9M by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy Alternatively let’s apply the same to humans: allow me to build o… | |
Post #AvVNB0uhYmUBMtLWJU by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy As long as certain countries allow to circumvent copyright for dtat… | |
Post #AvVNBAj15553nXxKUK by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy I'd love to pick your brains about this particular news. From w… | |
Post #AvVNBApOhMBW7KwQQy by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@doctormo Sure! But I think the four links on their Github https://github.com/c… | |
Post #AvVNBCI9FwmEenOtt2 by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @creativecommons "a new pact" wow take that Big Tech 😂 | |
Post #AvVNBOzU2eZU2flg6C by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy This thing, along with the IETF draft that it is built upon, seems … | |
Post #AvVNCBL6HaNpzcFcSO by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@skobkin @untsuki You are human, your brain will only learn what you like. What… | |
Post #AvVNCBRpsXlsKVOzxI by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @untsuki @skobkin Additionally, I for one am perfectly willing to m… | |
Post #AvVNCCTI4cWrVJ5frU by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy Heh, I notice one of the signals isn't "fuck off", bu… | |
Post #AvVNDhiPOYsgh7sYq0 by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @creativecommons What a shame, creative commons. What would Aaron t… | |
Post #AvVNDu2hYwFAvXSw8O by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@[email protected] The fact that there isn't a "no AI us… | |
Post #AvVNDyKvb7CSFE1Y6C by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @creativecommons I agree with you, And you gotta excuse me for my l… | |
Post #AvVNDyRJDOIuZ10e2q by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@Ray_Of_Sunlight @davidrevoy @creativecommons and then self yeet into the sun. | |
Post #AvVNET4LKpLxYlVF3I by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @ms_zwiebel @creativecommons My understanding is `ai=n` would mean … | |
Post #AvVNEbyIEgrTAbk2N6 by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@skobkin @untsuki If the AI dataset has a CC-By input, the output is a derivati… | |
Post #AvVNEeSUzMDAsrtBjM by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@ms_zwiebel @davidrevoy Exactly! The point of a license is to show what you *ar… | |
Post #AvVNF47Ta8qOTCFlZY by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@Merovius @davidrevoy @ms_zwiebel @creativecommons so I read all this in light … | |
Post #AvVNFCWELzOmWHteGe by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@f4grx @davidrevoy @creativecommons Hey, good idea | |
Post #AvVNFqe5ADRkyDsU3k by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@skobkin @davidrevoy @untsuki > But that's not how generative models wor… | |
Post #AvVNFsBnQM0bl4evFQ by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@Linebyline @ms_zwiebel I agree completely. The ideal would be to not have to o… | |
Post #AvVNFxRvrmt44ZFNaq by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@deathkitten @creativecommons Yes, we clearly need a NOAI in the CC toolset of … | |
Post #AvVNFxb9JWGAX9YjxY by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @deathkitten @creativecommons +1, with the caveat that i’d prefer… | |
Post #AvVNGB8EznSEVY8qqO by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@[email protected] @[email protected] whenever a company w… | |
Post #AvVNGBEGdOH6oExfEm by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@lamb @davidrevoy @creativecommons There's an executive trying to find new … | |
Post #AvVNH3bsRpFLT6QHXE by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@[email protected] I certainly wouldn't hold my breath of that actua… | |
Post #AvVNIHVSGbGcrC0E4m by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@drikanis @davidrevoy @creativecommons Yeah, what we need is a way to prove tha… | |
Post #AvVNIHcBrYefC59bZg by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@alxlg @drikanis @creativecommons https://haveibeentrained.com does a pretty go… | |
Post #AvVNIW6TzjCk85Qzjc by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@[email protected] @[email protected] @[email protected] Ye… | |
Post #AvVNIbMyPqMmSgBjdI by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@breizh you don’t need NC for that.AI’s don’t attribute properly.The only… | |
Post #AvVNIrrh5ORlcagUjo by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@skobkin @davidrevoy From how I see it CC-BY licensed art is allowed for machin… | |
Post #AvVNJSwFFR4WbQ69T6 by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy you can use this NOAI license until someone makes a better one 😇… | |
Post #AvVNJYXePmxpysday0 by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @creativecommons The people most affected are the experts here.We s… | |
Post #AvVNKM5iBwKBehwzMO by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@breizh @creativecommons @ArneBab True! | |
Post #AvVNKehazpK7NPoUuO by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @alxlg @drikanis @creativecommons This exploitation of artists from… | |
Post #AvVNKgdPoLATN1sBfc by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@skobkin @davidrevoy Of course, it's an open ended question and a philosoph… | |
Post #AvVNKvHdLbeononVIm by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@[email protected] @[email protected] @[email protected] cop… | |
Post #AvVNLngJ65TnVykyG0 by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@ArneBab @creativecommons Very true. I wish they could help creators and huge C… | |
Post #AvVNLqK5HAUBhvNlXE by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @creativecommons Seconding this, all of it. | |
Post #AvVNM7Ki265SSmo0My by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @creativecommons I just read this and... I have no idea what they&#… | |
Post #AvVNM7R5eNBumZn6Jc by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@knbrindle @creativecommons I think you understood the point correctly, immedia… | |
Post #AvVNMFCqlCYOsjBqEK by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@skobkin In my final sentence, the 'right people' metaphor clearly refe… | |
Post #AvVPuSKSfzyjKrBvQO by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @creativecommons that's... sad. I totally support free culture … | |
Post #AvVRrXJHtsZFp7NUKO by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
@davidrevoy"Expanding copyright to control AI training risks stifling inno… | |
Post #AvVS6t9cxyVBuqBDRQ by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
@davidrevoy"Expanding copyright to control AI training risks stifling inno… | |
Post #AvVjQBpdRjNuZ9cNXc by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
Yep. I have a rant about that (and a link to the github issue pointing that ou… | |
Post #AvVjp5jfFW1gtkhPay by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
@dgouttegattat at least the IETF draft allows you to specify that it shouldn… | |
Post #AvWA8Y8sSJkpJIQo2C by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @ArneBab @creativecommons At first I thought that NOAI felt wrong a… | |
Post #AvWA8YFG4arHd5Ptyq by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@gorobar The NOAI can still be useful -- because EU rules specify that artists … | |
Post #AvWA8YOpV0Vy6ltXto by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@ArneBab @gorobar @davidrevoy @creativecommons "In other words, Art. 4 rig… | |
Post #AvWA8YVZ5xu0Rf2vOi by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@skaphle It is ignored -- but that makes them liable for copyright infringement… | |
Post #AvWAEP6GzEML0L0Ls8 by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@Linebyline @ms_zwiebel @davidrevoy There is some flaw in your reasoning. Not o… | |
Post #AvWAEPEQUushPcora4 by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@Linebyline @davidrevoy @ms_zwiebel now what I cannot tell you is if such a exp… | |
Post #AvWAaQay6myK0ordj6 by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@carl @davidrevoy @creativecommons @rick As I mentioned elsewhere in the thread… | |
Post #AvWAbf5PiUU1FFh1jU by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@Merovius @carl @davidrevoy @creativecommons @rick if that’s the case, they m… | |
Post #AvWAbfC9JRs3a8qPEO by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@janvhs @carl @davidrevoy @creativecommons @rick Yes, based on the general feed… | |
Post #AvWAcS7ZPGK5K84wOe by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@ms_zwiebel @davidrevoy @creativecommons unless the concept of NOAI is the defa… | |
Post #AvWAkkkK2ijNPAA9A0 by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@stefan @davidrevoy @Linebyline @ms_zwiebel "How do I tell AI this. Its no… | |
Post #AvWAkl6Ij0JOVKRhQ0 by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@stefan @davidrevoy @Linebyline @ms_zwiebel This is a matter of legal principle… | |
Post #AvWB6JtmXdigVfs51k by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@carl @davidrevoy @creativecommons One of them is Open: "only allow reuse … | |
Post #AvWBYIBoUQSJJjdxs8 by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @ms_zwiebel @creativecommons Unfortunately, there is no mention of … | |
Post #AvWDDnkm8mI72QLzlo by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@Offbeatmammal @ms_zwiebel @davidrevoy @creativecommons It also requires a broa… | |
Post #AvWDHllJUCtG1KUtlI by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@r3vlibre I was specifically responding to the accusation that the CC design le… | |
Post #AvWoORAS9QmmTkIayu by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
Whoops. Discussion on the github pointed out to me that the CC proposal builds… | |
Post #AvYpYQ9zExu4WJKDoW by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @creativecommons Fucking hell. Next time I see a ✨ on something I… | |
Post #AvYpYVHcC1yaPPvstk by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@indigoviolet @creativecommons Oh yes, +1 and seeing the CC logo and this thing… | |
Post #AvabwsI3ILGRfimelU by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @ArneBab @creativecommons While you're at it, make the attribut… | |
Post #AvabwsQYmi4O66lS1g by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@StarkRG they *could* retain which input files affected which neurons and then … | |
Post #AvabwsXINfSQQzupWa by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@ArneBab @davidrevoy Well, that's certainly interesting. Seems like a whole… | |
Post #AvhErDBRlLqftYkD7A by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy "building a more equitable, sustainable AI ecosystem rooted in… | |
Post #AvhErDJFIM5SHkORGq by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@leah @davidrevoy @creativecommons yep what we want is just *less tigers eating… | |
Post #AvhErDQKrzl4dji6K0 by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@f4grx @leah @davidrevoy Today sounds like an excellent time to bring up Nights… | |
Post #AvhErDYqMMZ147gtaC by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@vansice @f4grx @leah Not FLOSS + not for Linux = no thanks. Also, it is not kn… | |
Post #AvhErDfDydfTNufzWq by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @vansice @f4grx and also again: I don't want to do the work bec… | |
Post #AvkzB4Au94Yr71mAeu by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @ArneBab while that sounds reasonable at first glance, it is questi… | |
Post #AvkzTSba3LGe5t1ZVg by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @ArneBab @creativecommons isn't output from AI actually public … | |
Post #AvkzTSiJeIegQmAx0a by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@prinlu that is still to be found out.AI does not *add* copyright to content, b… | |
Post #AvkzTSplCcbsnretc0 by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@ArneBab @prinlu @creativecommons Yes, and also you might accidentally get an A… | |
Post #Avkza4kHA3q07aFIzA by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy as an aside to this: you can see how much this is about power when … | |
Post #Avkza4riiNnCUfjFaa by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@ArneBab @davidrevoy @prinlu @creativecommons Allow me to rephrase the last sen… | |
Post #Avkzj5ZHTKBtHMOuxM by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @creativecommons I don't get what this is even supposed to acco… | |
Post #AvkznsMnytgRmfqeFE by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@Offbeatmammal @ms_zwiebel @davidrevoy @creativecommons crawlers respect nothin… | |
Post #Avkzrm2zQ3cpLIRExM by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@Linebyline @ms_zwiebel @davidrevoy especially since they will ignore it and si… | |
Post #Avl0Cxw0PwnKI9HDV2 by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@eobet @davidrevoy "NonFuckingCorporate means that Licensed Material is ma… | |
Post #Aw2nLZGjgwTVq91VPk by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @ArneBab @creativecommons hmmm..."Under current law, content p… | |
Post #Aw2nLZPb9zZ2HdAaEC by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@prinlu under current *US* law.Those decisions are being disputed, though.@davi… | |
Post #Aw2nLZX2iJWEeieWpc by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@ArneBab @prinlu @creativecommons I wish it was so simple as claiming that ever… | |
Post #Aw2nLZfYCgKB56dK5o by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @ArneBab @prinlu @creativecommons Regarding this and your previous … | |
Post #Aw2p46WjV4qXgSJ2qu by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @ArneBab @creativecommons well, in the US that was tried in the cou… | |
Post #Aw2p46cl8ffPz97rFI by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@prinlu @ArneBab @creativecommons No: the court refused the author of "A R… | |
Post #Aw2p46jqiJL2L8RWIS by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @prinlu @ArneBab @creativecommons But I heard that in the Midjourne… | |
Post #Aw2pcPeOuBo2qBFhbc by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @ArneBab @prinlu @creativecommons In the blog post the other commen… | |
Post #Aw2qMmumk2BeJY1snI by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @ArneBab @prinlu @creativecommons I don't it's feasible to … | |
Post #Aw2qkTSYj9SkvP7aFM by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
@davidrevoy @ArneBab @prinlu @creativecommons For image generation it's har… | |
Post #Aw3KY8KyQmyIZ5bZ8y by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@natsume_shokogami they could tag the virtual neurons with the training data th… | |
Post #Aw3KY8SlxnD4xHFnIe by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
@ArneBab @davidrevoy @prinlu @creativecommons What is the research for that?And… | |
Post #Aw3MmzOWA87j56TSOe by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
@ArneBab @davidrevoy @prinlu @creativecommons Also one thing I know about many … | |
Post #Aw3b8Ew8yD5KizEIgi by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@natsume_shokogami calling that false positives wouldn’t be correct: the neur… | |
Post #Aw3b8F3aWX2X64iFI8 by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
@ArneBab @davidrevoy @prinlu @creativecommons It seems like (my opinion, sorry … | |
Post #Aw3bzOl7BMgkXFQ264 by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
@ArneBab @davidrevoy @prinlu @creativecommons While the second paper is about m… | |
Post #Aw3cJ9VXaz6X1gYOOW by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@natsume_shokogami that’s one of the current ways, yes.I looked up some resea… | |
Post #Aw3cJ9bZEZvPKNNCmu by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
@ArneBab @davidrevoy @prinlu @creativecommons One of the issues of the first pa… | |
Post #Aw3cjRPtdJ6g6CRttg by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
@ArneBab @davidrevoy @prinlu @creativecommons The second and third paper are mu… | |
Post #Aw3diKYFlvpYTIONWa by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 0 repeats | |
@ArneBab @davidrevoy @prinlu @creativecommons But because these mathematical mo… | |
Post #Aw3diKfLLZVApHi2Zk by [email protected] | |
0 likes, 1 repeats | |
@ArneBab @davidrevoy @prinlu @creativecommons Also for LLMs and most generative… |