(C) Daily Kos
This story was originally published by Daily Kos and is unaltered.
. . . . . . . . . .
A Candlelight Vigil for Free Speech [1]
['This Content Is Not Subject To Review Daily Kos Staff Prior To Publication.']
Date: 2025-09-17
The suspension of Jimmy Kimmel after his remarks on Charlie Kirk’s horrific death should shake every American who still believes in the promise of free speech. We are living in an era where words that wander beyond the boundaries of political acceptability are not answered with debate—they are crushed with punishment. The reflex is no longer dialogue, but discipline: suspension, firing, investigation. What we are witnessing is not the strengthening of democracy, but its slow suffocation, one reprimand at a time.
The last month has been a brutal reminder of how fragile speech has become. After Kirk’s assassination, teachers across the nation were dragged from classrooms—suspended, investigated, stripped of their certifications—for posts deemed offensive. Professors like Felicia Branch at the University of Arkansas at Little Rock were suspended for comments that once might have sparked debate but now spark only condemnation. A student at Texas State was expelled for mocking Kirk at a vigil, his youthful irreverence treated as a crime. MSNBC cut ties with Matthew Dowd for “insensitive” remarks. And now, Kimmel has been silenced—late-night comedy itself, long a stage for irreverence and critique, pulled into the dragnet of censorship.
And he is far from alone. Stephen Colbert’s show has been muzzled with “editorial oversight” for jokes that bite too deeply. 60 Minutes—once fearless, once unflinching—now censors itself when its stories cast too harsh a light on the powerful. Joy Reid, among the most forthright voices on television, was removed—not for spreading lies, but for daring to speak bluntly about race, power, and accountability. When comedians, journalists, professors, teachers, and even students are all gagged by the threat of discipline, the result is not healthy discourse. It is the slow asphyxiation of dissent.
The message could not be clearer: no one is safe. Say the wrong thing, write the wrong post, deliver the wrong joke, and you could be finished. Institutions that once prided themselves on fostering debate have instead chosen to enforce conformity, terrified of backlash and desperate to prove their loyalty to the loudest voices in the room. In this climate, the very essence of free speech—the right to say what others may despise without fear of exile—has been reduced to ashes.
We have seen this before. From the Red Scare to the post-9/11 silencing of dissent, America has too often confused obedience with patriotism. Today’s wave of suspensions and firings is not about protecting the public; it is about enforcing orthodoxy. And orthodoxy, whether imposed by government, corporations, or mob outrage, has always been the sworn enemy of democracy.
Let us be clear: this is not about defending cruelty or celebrating tragedy. It is about recognizing that the line between bad taste and punishable offense has been obliterated. Any comment—satirical, political, offhand—can now be a career-ending move if it collides with prevailing sentiment. That is not freedom. That is managed speech disguised as public order.
Free speech in America is not dying with one dramatic blow. It is dying by a thousand cuts. Each suspension, each firing, each expulsion chips away at the fragile space where dissent lives. It dies when comedians are pulled off the air, when professors are sidelined, when journalists are silenced, when students are punished—all for words. And it dies most of all when ordinary people, watching the punishment of others, fall into silence out of fear.
This is why we need a candlelight vigil—not only for the victims of violence, but for the freedom to speak honestly about that violence. To mourn free speech is not to celebrate every reckless word, but to understand that without space for reckless speech, thoughtful speech cannot survive either. If we do not reclaim that space now, the flame of democratic discourse will gutter out, leaving us in darkness.
[END]
---
[1] Url:
https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2025/9/17/2344109/-A-Candlelight-Vigil-for-Free-Speech?pm_campaign=front_page&pm_source=latest_community&pm_medium=web
Published and (C) by Daily Kos
Content appears here under this condition or license: Site content may be used for any purpose without permission unless otherwise specified.
via Magical.Fish Gopher News Feeds:
gopher://magical.fish/1/feeds/news/dailykos/
