(C) Daily Kos
This story was originally published by Daily Kos and is unaltered.
. . . . . . . . . .



Stephen Miller’s Second Act: The Rat Beneath Trump’s Big Top [1]

['This Content Is Not Subject To Review Daily Kos Staff Prior To Publication.']

Date: 2025-07-18

How Trump’s faded circus has become the perfect cover for Miller’s relentless project: a country remade by fear, exclusion, and quiet cruelty.

It’s easy to underestimate Stephen Miller. In fact, it’s practically a national pastime — helped along by his sallow, half-vampiric appearance and a public speaking cadence that suggests he was once bullied by punctuation. Even his ideological enemies often dismiss him as little more than a cartoonish bigot in an ill-fitting suit, a goth hall monitor finally given a badge and a nightstick.

But the reality is far darker and far more dangerous. Miller is not merely Trumpism’s ghoulish mascot; he is its meticulous engineer. If Donald Trump is the buffoonish ringmaster clowning about on center stage, Miller is the rat under the bleachers, quietly gnawing at the tent poles. And with Trump back in office, Miller’s second act is shaping up to be even more destructive than the first.

The lingering stench of Act I

Miller’s first tour of duty left the country with scars that still haven’t healed. As Trump’s senior policy adviser and the architect behind his most notorious immigration policies, Miller proved that cruelty could be systematized with chilling efficiency. Family separations at the border weren’t a bureaucratic misfire — they were the policy. Asylum caps weren’t an accident — they were the objective. In Miller’s world, inflicting maximum pain was a feature, not a bug, meant to dissuade anyone from believing America’s golden door still swung on its hinges.

Even after the Trump administration lumbered out of Washington in January 2021, trailing lawsuits and unpaid contractors like tin cans tied to its tail, Miller never stopped working. He launched America First Legal, a sort of lawsuit factory cum idea shop dedicated to ensuring that his brand of hardline nativism remained alive in the federal bloodstream. Through strategic litigation, lobbying, and endless media whisper campaigns, he kept pushing the Overton window toward a darker horizon.

That means Miller wasn’t starting from scratch when Trump returned to power. He was stepping back onto a stage he’d never fully exited — only now with an expanded arsenal of precedents, court rulings, and sympathetic judges hand-picked during the first MAGA administration.

The second term: Miller unleashed

What makes Miller so uniquely perilous in Trump’s encore is that he himself is more diminished, distracted, and desperate for personal absolution. In the first term, Trump often had to be led around by the nose, with advisers like Miller quietly slipping policy drafts under his door. However, with Trump fighting for his survival against legal and financial ruin, Miller’s influence is only magnified in this new term. Trump wants loyalty and vengeance; Miller wants ideological conquest. That makes them unsettlingly compatible.

Reports from inside the West Wing already describe Miller as the most powerful man in the building — the real prime minister of Trump’s America. His fingerprints are on every new immigration order, from expanded “Remain in Mexico” schemes to whispered plans for mass deportation raids designed to swamp urban areas with ICE flashpoints. Where Trump is content with the spectacle of cruelty, Miller craves its machinery. He wants systems that run even when the cameras shut off, dark engines humming away to purge the country of those he deems undesirable.

It’s worth noting that Miller doesn’t limit his sights to migrants at the southern border. Under his second-term designs, the nation is seeing a profound escalation: targeting sanctuary cities with federal retaliation, expanding immigration courts into rapid-fire deportation mills, even exploring federal contract requirements that privilege “citizen labor” in industries reliant on immigrant workers. This bigotry is an architecture of exclusion so vast it makes the first term’s border wall look like a quaint garden fence.

A hollow clown, a meticulous malice

For Trump, none of this is particularly ideological. His interest in immigration is about using applause lines, spectacle, and the satisfaction of punishing perceived enemies. Miller, by contrast, is an obsessive. His speeches are dotted with references to “Western civilization,” his private memos spill over with allusions to demographic “invasion,” and his work after hours — through America First Legal — shows a grim determination to change the character of the United States permanently.

And here lies the bleak genius of the arrangement: Trump needs adoring rallies and Fox News segments to stay afloat. He’ll sign anything that earns him a cheer. Meanwhile, Miller needs only Trump’s pen and his disinterest in fine print. The result is a Faustian pact where Miller writes the script, Trump performs it, and the country pays the ticket price, often with its soul.

Hangover politics: why Miller matters more now

It’s tempting to think that Miller is just a holdover from Trump’s first maladministration, still chasing his white whale of mass deportations because he knows nothing else. But that underestimates how the country has changed. The judiciary is now stacked with Trump-era appointees who are more receptive to Miller’s arguments. Congress is sufficiently gridlocked that executive orders are once again the primary means of domestic policy. And the GOP’s internal shift toward outright ethnonationalism gives Miller a cheering section that would have seemed fringy even in 2017.

Miller’s second act isn’t about replaying old hits. It’s about institutionalizing them. He is working to embed a vision of America that is not merely hostile to new arrivals, but actively suspicious of anyone who doesn’t fit his narrow definition of cultural legitimacy. That means more workplace raids, more citizenship verification crackdowns, and more efforts to starve states and cities that dare to resist federal immigration dictates.

The bigger stage: Miller’s quiet global project

Many miss that Miller sees immigration not just as a domestic nuisance, but as a civilizational contest. He is deeply plugged into European far-right circles, often citing policies out of Hungary and Poland as proof points that “national identity” can be fortified by sheer force of law. Under Trump 2.0, Miller has begun steering diplomatic relationships toward an axis of anti-immigrant solidarity, pushing back against international refugee compacts and withholding aid from countries that fail to crack down on outbound migration.

This heavy-handedness represents Miller’s empire of exclusion: one that links ICE raids in San Diego to anti-migrant fences in Slovenia, all under the flattering banner of protecting the “Western way of life.” It’s an ugly, regressive vision that mistakes homogeneity for strength and fear for policy.

What comes after the clown show?

If there’s a tragic irony here, it’s that Stephen Miller probably owes everything to Donald Trump — and yet is far more capable of reshaping the country than Trump ever was on his own. Trump’s appeal has always been theatrical, a pageant of grievance meant to keep cameras rolling and cash flowing. Miller’s ambition is colder, quieter, and much more enduring. Where Trump will eventually leave the stage — chased off by creditors, cardiac arrest, or simply a bored electorate — Miller’s policies are designed to linger, to calcify in the bloodstream of government until even future presidents struggle to excise them.

That’s why paying attention to Miller now is so critical. He is the shadow at the edge of the spotlight, the small, unsmiling figure whispering stage directions that can outlast any showman. The Big Top will fold eventually — but by then, the tent stakes will be driven so deep that pulling them up will tear up half the fairground.

A final note from under the bleachers

So yes, it’s easy to laugh at Stephen Miller’s spectral pallor, grandiose diction, and penchant for quoting long-dead historians to justify living cruelties. It’s almost comforting to imagine him as just another court weirdo, forever chasing Trump around the Oval Office with color-coded flowcharts. But that would be a mistake — the same mistake too many made the first time.

Miller isn’t chasing Trump; he’s chasing something far bigger: a country that looks more like him and less like us. And this time, he’s already got the blueprints ready.

~Dunneagin

This is part of my ongoing series on Trump’s second term. More essays & satire at dunneagin.substack.com — where the tent’s always open (for a small fee to feed the elephants).

[END]
---
[1] Url: https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2025/7/18/2333603/-Stephen-Miller-s-Second-Act-The-Rat-Beneath-Trump-s-Big-Top?pm_campaign=front_page&pm_source=more_community&pm_medium=web

Published and (C) by Daily Kos
Content appears here under this condition or license: Site content may be used for any purpose without permission unless otherwise specified.

via Magical.Fish Gopher News Feeds:
gopher://magical.fish/1/feeds/news/dailykos/