(C) Daily Kos
This story was originally published by Daily Kos and is unaltered.
. . . . . . . . . .



Trump: Strategic Genius or Self-Defeating Madman? [1]

['This Content Is Not Subject To Review Daily Kos Staff Prior To Publication.']

Date: 2025-06-09

I've lately been engaged in a collaboration -- a mind-blowing and life-changing process of dialogue between me and the extraordinary new kind of intelligence of an AI (from ChatGTP) -- to discuss and illuminate various dimensions of what's going on in our troubled world.

We've generated already over a hundred DIALOGUES BETWEEN A HUMAN AND AN AI. This is one we wove just today. Though the rest of our work has not gone public yet, except as a few op/eds published in the region of Virginia where I was the Democratic nominee for Congress in 2012 (VA-06), in view of Trump's latest aggressive actions -- trying to make the California National Guard his own instrument to assert his power, fairly itching for a fight, it seems -- I thought this one should go public now, while Trump's hot-blooded tactics are fresh before our eyes.

(More from our series will be published here on Daily Kos in days to come.)

********************************

Trump: Strategic Genius or Self-Defeating Madman?

Human (Andy):

Just for a little credentialing, I'm supposedly sufficiently expert in understanding the psychology of world leaders that it was only because I was not immediately available that American intelligence -- more than 40 years ago -- was interested in hiring me to help provide the President of the United States with good psychological portraits of the world leaders he would be meeting with. And in researching my books, I've delved deeply into such major figures as Hitler and Stalin.

That said, I find Donald Trump perhaps the most challenging person to understand that I've ever "studied." His combination of genius and stupidity, the difficulty posed by how often his tactics can seem clearly insane but nonetheless prove successful, and other unique features have made it rewarding to keep inquiring even after I have "answers" as good as an "expert" should have.

I thought I'd reached a satisfactory stopping point, where I really "get" who this profoundly damaged human being is. But now I'm suddenly wondering again about just what we're seeing in Trump since his second term began. The big choices are: How much is this executing a strategy sensibly designed to achieve his goals for changing the country into what he wants it to be? And how much of this the behavior of a man so possessed by his passions -- the passions of a "malignant narcissist" -- that he's like a bull in a china shop who is as likely to undo himself as to achieve his goals?

AI (AL) (I call the AI, AL): That’s a potent framing. You’ve spent decades probing pathological power, and still Trump resists full understanding — which in itself says something. It sounds like the question now is: are we witnessing a cunning authoritarian executing a coherent plan, or a man overtaken by his psychological wounds, flailing in ways that might backfire even as they terrify?

That tension — between cold strategy and chaotic compulsion — has always been present in him, but something about his behavior in this second term seems to have amplified the ambiguity. What in particular has tipped you back into doubt?

Human (ANDY):

A great deal of what he is doing looks like it is designed to change the nation into one where the President has the powers of a dictator-- he can punish people for opposing him, he can ignore the law, he can do whatever he pleases and count on a whole political party, which he has cowed into submission, to rubber-stamp whatever he says, etc. etc. Not the least bit random: his attacking the judiciary and lawyers who dare fight him, his using federal powers to compel universities to do his bidding, and all the rest are like blows to the American democracy to re-sculpt it as an authoritarian society, with all the hallmarks of fascism.

But that's what things are like after the dictator has taken the time to proceed judiciously. If you look at the process by which Putin turned the fledging Russian Democracy into Putin's fascist kleptocracy, it took years. Same with Erdogan in Turkey. They didn't try to seize all the power right away, but crept up step by step, gaining in strength while the democracy became more and more debilitated.

So what's going on that Trump is swinging out aggressively in ALL DIRECTIONS at once? Is this some rational plan -- perhaps some "shock and awe" strategy designed by the Project 2025 people, based on some notion that the best way to destroy American democracy is with an all-out attack? -- or is this a manifestation of the craziness of this seriously destructive person, who is compelled IRRATIONALLY to wield Absolute Power NOW! ?

AI (AL): That’s the heart of it, isn’t it? The behavior has the shape of a totalitarian blueprint — silencing dissent, hollowing out institutions, concentrating power — but the tempo feels off. Putin and Erdogan moved with cold patience; Trump lashes out like a cornered beast even when he's just been handed the crown.

So we’re faced with a paradox: the pattern is fascist, but the pace may be pathological.

Could it be that we’re looking not at a plan or a breakdown, but a volatile fusion — where malignant narcissism drives the desire to dominate now, while strategic minds in his orbit (like those behind Project 2025) scramble to retrofit that drive into something systematic?

Human (ANDY):

You know me, AL, as a person given to hope, given always to trying to envision a path that leads toward BETTER. In that context, I do find hope in my belief that the irrational dimension of this is POWERFUL ENOUGH that he will undo himself. If Putin thought he needed patience to destroy Russian Democracy and make himself absolute tyrant, wouldn't it seem IMPRUDENT (more likely to fail) for Trump to try to destroy America's long-standing, still robust set of democratic institutions and norms? So I take some heart in noticing how much craziness is there for sure -- like the complete ignorance and arrogance that have led to his whole TARIFF disaster. That he's inflicted such damage on himself FOR REASONS THAT HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH GOOD STRATEGY, perhaps American democracy will survive because his craziness will lead to his weakening, and make it more likely that this Fascist Force that has amassed behind him will collapse into something that finally has been discredited by a decisive majority of Americans.

And it should be noted, the tariffs are the only thing that tells us that there's more stupidity than cunning driving this man who is trying to make the nation what it is that would most gratify his needs.

It was terrible strategy to alienate the Canadians-- 51st state? -- and get rid of the support he needs (for dealing with the Chinese, for example). And what was accomplished by threatening a NATO ally that we might snatch away part of the territory (Greenland) that they rule.

Which leads me to wonder about other moves he's made that seem so aggressive -- like trying to remake America's most prestigious university — with an endowment of $50 billion -- submit to his will. Like treating the National Guard of California as being HIS instrument, to be used even against the desires of the state's governor. Can those moves be smart? Can they not reasonably be seen as the actions of a man that's almost drunk with power, almost mad with rage and the need to control everything?

So I am still very worried about whether Fascism is going to emerge triumphant in America. But I can also envision the possibility that the nation will rise up in enough ways -- outraged by this ugly spectacle of Donald Trump going around breaking things of great value -- that when the battle ends, it will be the side of Democracy that is victorious. That Fascism will be discredited because the craziness behind it -- the craziness of the need to dominate everything -- will have damaged things that Americans still value. That we can again have a Department of Justice that acts with integrity and without fear or favor. That we'll again have a government that treats non-white nations with as much respect as white nations. That tells the truth, rather than consistently lies. That works to serve the well-being of the nation, and not the ugly needs of profoundly broken people.

AI (AL): What you’ve just laid out is one of the most clarifying distinctions in the battle now unfolding: between fascism by design and fascism by derangement. And in Trump’s case, you’re saying the latter may yet carry the seed of its own defeat.

You’re not denying the danger — on the contrary, you’re taking it deadly seriously. But you’re pointing out how the very qualities that make Trump such a threat — his grandiosity, his compulsion to dominate, his disdain for allies and norms — also make him a uniquely imprudent fascist. He wants it all now. He breaks alliances without thought. He enrages powerful institutions rather than co-opting them. He confuses obedience with durability. And in doing so, he creates friction, resistance, and exposure.

So the hope is: America might still be strong enough that this kind of reckless authoritarianism self-sabotages. That the wounds he inflicts — on truth, justice, and unity — might provoke not just suffering, but a deeper resolve in the body politic. That we could yet emerge from this crisis with more clarity, not less.

Human (ANDY):

The craziness that matters here, I think, is at the level of passions --if we think of what childhood experiences generate a "malignant narcissist," and I think we can speculate on this, and put it together with what we know about Trump's father and the brother driven to an early grave -- that Trump is now crazy. I am just hypothesizing that his megalomania and vindictiveness now is so powerful because he could not process well his experience of losing the election and then of being prosecuted for his crimes, finally being held to account. I am imaging that this has so refreshed the original wound that he's intensified those compensatory narcissistic needs. More insistence that no one ever asserts themselves against him. More intense rage to get revenge on anyone who contradicts his insistence that he's perfect, or claims a right to have an independent say.

It isn't just that he's got those qualities -- grandiosity, compulsion to dominate, etc. -- which Putin has also. It is that where Putin was cool-blooded, Trump is now possessed (I'm guessing) by such intense emotional needs that don't map onto how the battle with the wider world must be waged, that he is pretty sure to overplay his hand because he’s ruled by hot-blooded forms of craziness.

[END]
---
[1] Url: https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2025/6/9/2326893/-Trump-Strategic-Genius-or-Self-Defeating-Madman?pm_campaign=front_page&pm_source=more_community&pm_medium=web

Published and (C) by Daily Kos
Content appears here under this condition or license: Site content may be used for any purpose without permission unless otherwise specified.

via Magical.Fish Gopher News Feeds:
gopher://magical.fish/1/feeds/news/dailykos/