(C) Daily Kos
This story was originally published by Daily Kos and is unaltered.
. . . . . . . . . .
MAKE AMERICA SWEAT AGAIN [1]
['This Content Is Not Subject To Review Daily Kos Staff Prior To Publication.']
Date: 2025-04-14
It was supposed to be a hammer. Instead, it’s become a boomerang.
When Donald Trump slapped 125% tariffs on Chinese imports this year, he promised an industrial renaissance. “We’re bringing our jobs back,” he declared at a rally in Michigan. “Real jobs. American jobs.” But like most strongman slogans, the reality is uglier—and far more complicated. The White House’s carve-outs for high-tech sectors like smartphones, semiconductors, and solar components reveal what the policy truly is: a sweeping, regressive tax that spares corporate titans and punishes the little guy.
It lets Asia have high tech; we’ll bring back the sweatshops.
It’s not high-skilled, high-wage manufacturing coming home. It’s low-margin sweatshop labor limping back under a flag. The tech sector gets exemptions. The textile importer in Omaha? She’s stuck with 145% duties and a customer base unwilling to pay triple for socks.
“No way to survive,” said Lisa Tran, who runs a family-owned apparel brand that sources bamboo fabrics from China. “I tried to absorb the costs, but it’s impossible. I’ll have to lay off half my team by July. And for what? To make T-shirts in Alabama at 30 cents an hour?”
That’s the paradox of Trump’s trade war. The administration insists it’s punishing China to protect American industry. But the industries it’s protecting are the ones least capable of generating value, while those capable of actual strategic competition—tech, energy, advanced manufacturing—are explicitly excluded from the pain.
“This is an industrial policy by tantrum,” said Jason Furman, former chair of the Council of Economic Advisers. “You don’t reshore semiconductors by giving Apple a free pass while bankrupting every mid-sized manufacturer in the Midwest.”
The exemptions speak volumes. Smartphones, computers, chips, and solar cells were all spared, after aggressive lobbying from Silicon Valley. Apple alone flew in over 1.5 million iPhones from its Indian factories to avoid paying the new levies. Wedbush Securities called it a “dream scenario” for tech investors. For everyone else? A waking nightmare.
“We’ve seen a 23% increase in costs for basic plumbing components,” said Ray Maldonado, who owns a small HVAC repair company in Albuquerque. “Pipes, water heaters, thermostats—everything’s gone up. Our clients are pushing back. One guy told me, ‘Sorry man, I’ll wait until the water heater actually explodes.’”
Maldonado’s story isn’t unique. Across the country, small and medium-sized businesses are bearing the brunt. The sectors hardest hit—furniture, clothing, and small electronics—are also the least likely to be restored meaningfully. Most operate on razor-thin margins. They can’t afford to rebuild factories stateside, and the labor cost differential makes it infeasible even if they could.
In Kansas, Hendrick Svendsen closed his family’s furniture shop after 38 years. “I grew up stocking chairs in this store,” he told local reporters. “We used to get furniture from North Carolina. Now? China. We tried switching back, but domestic suppliers can’t match the price, and the customers walk.” He sighed. “People want ‘Made in America’ until they see the price tag.”
“Tariffs are just taxes in disguise,” said Michael Strain, director of economic policy at the American Enterprise Institute. “And like most regressive taxes, they hit the poor hardest.” A Tax Foundation analysis estimates the average U.S. household will pay an additional $1,280 per year under Trump’s new levies. For lower-income families, the burden can rise as high as $1,700.
It’s not just about money. It’s about strategy—or the lack of one.
Blanket tariffs, especially when layered with ad hoc exemptions, distort the very markets they claim to protect. By shielding sectors with lobbying muscle while punishing those without, they don’t restore critical supply chains—they just shuffle them. Tech companies stay offshore. Cheap goods become more expensive. And no meaningful industrial revival happens.
Compare that to Biden’s targeted strategy. His administration’s 100% tariffs on Chinese EVs and solar cells are paired with massive federal subsidies to scale domestic production. The CHIPS Act has already created 45,000 high-wage jobs in semiconductor fabrication. The Inflation Reduction Act has catalyzed $100 billion in clean energy investments. That’s what a real industrial strategy looks like: incentives, not blunt force trauma.
Even Republican economists are wary. “This isn’t protectionism. It’s economic vandalism,” said Douglas Holtz-Eakin, former director of the Congressional Budget Office. “If Trump really wanted to rebuild American industry, he’d be investing in infrastructure, workforce development, and R&D—not torching the global supply chain with a flamethrower.”
And it’s not just economists sounding the alarm.
“This could wipe us out entirely,” wrote a Nevada small business owner in a letter read aloud on the Senate floor by Senator Jacky Rosen. “We’d need to raise prices by 37%, and customers won’t accept that.”
Meanwhile, the industries that Trump supposedly wants to protect are hemorrhaging credibility. Stellantis, the parent company of Chrysler and Jeep, recently announced layoffs at its Illinois plant due to rising steel and parts costs. Walmart quietly revised its earnings forecast downward. The S&P 500 took a 19% hit post-tariff announcement. Apple hasn’t brought a single iPhone assembly job back to the U.S.—and doesn’t plan to.
“It would take three years and $30 billion to move even 10% of Apple’s supply chain out of Asia,” said Dan Ives of Wedbush. “It’s fantasy politics to think tariffs will bring those jobs back.”
The administration’s defenders say it’s all part of a longer game—that the pain now will lead to gain later. But history suggests otherwise. Trump’s 2018 solar tariffs backfired spectacularly, causing $3.4 billion in losses for downstream installers and barely nudging U.S. manufacturing. Most Chinese firms simply rerouted production through Vietnam and Malaysia—countries now also subject to Trump’s new tariffs, creating a circular mess of supply chain chaos.
“We were finally starting to recover from COVID disruptions,” said Jessica Nguyen, co-founder of a sustainable fashion startup in Portland. “Now, we’re paying nearly 150% tariffs on our raw fabric. I just had to cancel a spring collection. And I don’t know if we’ll survive the summer.”
So what’s the endgame? If it’s reviving American industry, this isn’t the way. If it’s hurting China, it’s not working. According to the U.S. Geological Survey, 72% of America’s rare earth minerals—vital for electronics and EVs—still come from China. And if the goal is to win over working-class voters, the numbers don’t back that up either. Job losses from tariff ripple effects are concentrated in construction, logistics, and retail—sectors where Trump’s base lives and works.
“This is not how you win a trade war,” said Mariana Mazzucato, professor of economics at University College London. “You don’t beat your competitor by lighting your own factories on fire.”
For a brief moment, the idea of reshoring manufacturing felt like a compelling narrative. Bring back the factories. Rebuild the middle class. But the execution has exposed the fantasy. Tariffs without strategy are just punishment—misdirected, blunt, and cruel.
We aren’t getting the future of work. We’re getting the past of work, dressed up in red, white, and blue. A few shuttered mills may sputter back to life. But the jobs that return—if any—will be low-skill, low-pay, and low-hope.
And the real industries of tomorrow? AI chips, quantum semiconductors, biomanufacturing—they’re staying in Shenzhen.
[END]
---
[1] Url:
https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2025/4/14/2316338/-MAKE-AMERICA-SWEAT-AGAIN?pm_campaign=front_page&pm_source=more_community&pm_medium=web
Published and (C) by Daily Kos
Content appears here under this condition or license: Site content may be used for any purpose without permission unless otherwise specified.
via Magical.Fish Gopher News Feeds:
gopher://magical.fish/1/feeds/news/dailykos/
