(C) Daily Kos
This story was originally published by Daily Kos and is unaltered.
. . . . . . . . . .



Caribbean Matters: Three weeks post-Fiona, Puerto Ricans still without power; the statehood debate [1]

['Backgroundurl Avatar_Large', 'Nickname', 'Joined', 'Created_At', 'Story Count', 'N_Stories', 'Comment Count', 'N_Comments', 'Popular Tags', 'Showtags Popular_Tags']

Date: 2022-10-13

This story presents the views of Puerto Ricans who do not support statehood for the island. Statehooders have a huge lobbying fund and “shadow government,” headed by deposed ex-Gov. Ricardo “Ricky” Rosselló, and hold most of the island’s highest offices, including the current position of governor, and the resident commissioner’s (non-voting) seat in Congress is held by Republican Jenniffer González, who claims she is no longer an avid Trump supporter. The pro-statehood forces have a big media platform, more access to mainstream media, and by virtue of power and position, they’re the ones who get the photo ops with President Joe Biden and members of Congress.

And so, here are several voices from the other side of the statehood conversation.

Check out this powerful OpEd on Puerto Rico in the @nytimes by Yarimar Bonilla @yarimarbonilla You can read it through this gift link without a subscription. https://t.co/x1Aubrb1G5

Sadly, there is no CBS transcript of this conversation with Bonilla; however, there are a few quotes in the longer story . Bonilla also authored an opinion piece for The New York Times this week. For those who don’t subscribe or have maxed out their free articles, I’ve gifted the story below.

There’s been a lot of change politically culturally & socially since hurricane Maria. @YarimarBonilla , a political anthropologist at @Hunter_College , spoke about that, & added: “continue to support us…but…let us define what we want Puerto Rico to be in the future.” pic.twitter.com/uioeygBJNL

Bonilla writes:

After Maria, the Federal Emergency Management Agency sank more than $1 billion into a doomed program called Tu Hogar Renace, or Your Home Reborn, which was meant to provide essential repairs to affected residences in Puerto Rico, reducing the demand for other shelter options. The program focused on basic repairs like fixing broken windows and doors but didn’t prepare structures to withstand future storms. Worse, it was gamed by contractors who charged exorbitant prices for shoddy subcontracted work. Public works have been similarly challenged. The most visible example is a temporary bridge, built by FEMA contractors in Ohio and placed in the town of Utuado in 2018, at a cost of nearly $3 million. It was supposed to last 75 years, but last month, Fiona’s surging floodwaters washed it down the river. The irony is that the bridge Maria had destroyed was also a temporary one built after Hurricane Georges in 1998. Puerto Ricans deserve more than Band-Aids that will be ripped away by the next disaster. We also need and deserve a faster recovery. It is unjustifiable and untenable that after a storm, residents are expected to spend weeks without electricity and years living under blue tarps. In the early months of the Covid pandemic, cash payments were released by the federal government with little bureaucratic friction because there was a clear sense of urgency. The same urgency needs to be brought to attending to a natural disaster.

Bonilla was also interviewed in late September by NPR’s Morning Edition, and expanded on some of the problems with FEMA noted above.

YARIMAR BONILLA: Well, part of it has to do with climate change. Of course. LEILA FADEL: Yeah. BONILLA: That means that these storms are coming faster and faster, but it also has to do with the fact that emergency response hasn't adapted to climate change. It's not rebuilding in time. And so some of the recovery in Puerto Rico has been extremely slow, part of it because of the bureaucracy of FEMA that takes a long time to release funds, that often does patchwork, temporary solutions, like this bridge that we all saw wash away like a twig because it couldn't even stand, you know, a Category 1 storm. FADEL: And this is a bridge that was rebuilt after... BONILLA: After Maria. FADEL: ...It was destroyed by Maria. Yeah. BONILLA: Yes, but it was a temporary bridge, and the permanent bridge, you know, was not even started yet. And, you know, part of it was also that FEMA funds, they're always slow, but they were overly policed when it came to Puerto Rico. They were held back. They were extremely vetted. And I'm talking here at the societal level. At the individual level as well, a disproportionate number of individuals never received FEMA payments from Maria in the first place to rebuild from Maria. And so we know that there were still people in their blue tarps or people who were never able to really fully repair their homes.

x Climate resilient infrastructure is important, but it won’t happen in Puerto Rico unless we look at the myriad ways colonialist policies have held it back. For @voxdotcom:https://t.co/X4O5XfmEKy — Izzie Ramirez (@IzzieRamirez) October 10, 2022

Izzie Ramirez, deputy editor of Future Perfect, also examined the obstacles faced by Puerto Rico this week.

… a major reason why Puerto Rico’s uptake on adaptation plans has been slow lies with the unique bureaucratic obstacles it faces because of its territorial status and pre-existing debt. Despite the money it did ultimately receive, Puerto Rico’s infrastructure is no better today than it was before María. In fact, it’s even worse. While Fiona was a much smaller storm than María, the hurricane revealed just how vulnerable the island remains. “Given that our collective ability to overcome these events has actually diminished since Hurricane María in 2017,” Raúl Santiago-Bartolomei, a professor of urban planning at the University of Puerto Rico, Río Piedras, told me by email, “both federal and local government policies in these areas have proven to be failures.” Puerto Rico’s vulnerability to hurricanes goes beyond its location on a highway of tropical storms. The island is a poor place by any calculation — with a median household income at $21,000 and a poverty rate hovering around 40 percent, Puerto Rico is twice as poor as Mississippi, the most impoverished American state. And poverty is what can help make natural disasters so deadly and dangerous. But much of the reason why Puerto Rico is so poor boils down in large part to the long-term consequences of colonialism, which has held the territory back from making progress. Although Biden likely has a better-intentioned game plan in mind for Puerto Rico’s recovery than his predecessor, the problems on the island run much deeper than poor electricity infrastructure and sea walls. According to activists and scholars in Puerto Rico and in the diaspora, adaptation plans alone won’t be enough to improve the lives of everyday people living on the island. There will need to be a major reevaluation of the colonialist underpinnings — the debt crisis and Puerto Rico’s political structure, for one — in order for any kind of climate-resilient infrastructure to happen.

A Sept. 22 opinion piece in The Seattle Times, by political scientist Jennaro Abraham, points out the negative impact of colonialism.

Acquired by the U.S. in 1898 by right of the Spanish-American War, Puerto Rico’s economy was molded to fit the extractive interests of the United States. Whether it be through the sugar industry (1900-1930s), industrial initiatives (1930s-1970s), tax exemptions reserved for intellectual property (1970s-2000s), or more recently, tax exemptions afforded to high-net-worth investors via the Act 20/22 (2012-present), Puerto Rico’s ability to develop an effective tax regime to fund basic government services has been compromised. The colonial state’s historical response to inadequate tax funds — coupled with prohibitive import costs imposed by a U.S. shipping monopoly — has been to indulge in unsustainable bond emissions, thus, resulting in a $73 billion-dollar public debt. As debt quickly accrued and tax revenue remained insufficient, operational funds for public services suffered, resulting in massive layoffs. These issues further perpetuated a longstanding brain drain which continues to shrink the archipelago’s tax base in the present. And as the nation’s ability to invest in basic infrastructure has dwindled, so has its ability to respond to — let alone rebuild — after hurricanes. Before this debt crisis, Congress — Puerto Rico’s ultimate legal authority — responded by imposing a fiscal oversight board to ensure debt repayment. However, rather than helping the nation prosper, the congressionally appointed board decided to withhold necessary funds to education, essential government services and even disaster recovery funds after hurricane Irma and Maria had hit, all while privatizing the nation’s electrical grid, thus complicating the nation’s sustainability even further.

Last, but certainly not least, Puerto Rican author Jaquira Diaz issued a plea for independence in The Atlantic: “Let Puerto Rico be Free.”

[END]
---
[1] Url: https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2022/10/13/2128078/-Caribbean-Matters-Three-weeks-post-Fiona-Puerto-Ricans-still-without-power-the-statehood-debate

Published and (C) by Daily Kos
Content appears here under this condition or license: Site content may be used for any purpose without permission unless otherwise specified.

via Magical.Fish Gopher News Feeds:
gopher://magical.fish/1/feeds/news/dailykos/