From
[email protected] Apr 8 11:31:57 1995
Date: Wed, 28 Sep 1994 23:46:09 +0100
From: Bernhard Helander <
[email protected]>
To:
[email protected]
Subject: Somalia News Update, No 24
In this issue:
* THE LOOTERS IN HUDDUR
* LOCAL POLICE SHEDS NEW LIGHT ON HOSPITAL KILLINGS
* FROM TRANQUILLITY TO FIGHTING: THE SAD OUTCOME OF THE SSDF CONGRESS
* REVIEW OF MOHAMED SAHNOUN'S BOOK
____________________________________________________________________
S O M A L I A N E W S U P D A T E
____________________________________________________________________
Vol 3, No 24 September 28, 1994. ISSN 1103-1999
____________________________________________________________________
Somalia News Update is published irregularly via electronic mail and
fax. Questions can be directed to
[email protected] or
to fax number +46-18-151160. All SNU marked material is free to
quote as long as the source is clearly stated.
____________________________________________________________________
THE LOOTERS IN HUDDUR
Somalia News Update (Uppsala, September 25) - The recent fire fight
between UN peacekeepers and Somali militias in Balad is described in
the Secretary-Generals September report to the Security Council as
having originated from the militias wish to lay hands on the
equipment left behind by the troops. However, as Somalia News
Updates reporter witnessed in Huddur on September 5, there is very
little worth looting once UN troops pull out.
"Whatever they couldn't take with them, they smashed to pieces",
says SNU's reporter who had spent the night with the elders of the
city in an emergency meeting trying to deal with the sudden and
unannounced departure of the troops. "In the early morning hours,
just after the last UNOSOM troops had left, we walked over to the
former UNOSOM headquarters in Huddur. There was absolutely nothing
left behind. The water pipes had been destroyed and even the electric
wires in the ceiling cut to pieces".
The clan elders of the Bakool region rapidly formed an inter-
clan militia to safeguard the security of the area. The World Food
Programme, whose officers first left with UNOSOM, returned to the
city after a few days. After UNOSOM looted their own office, no
further incidents have been reported.
LOCAL POLICE SHEDS NEW LIGHT ON HOSPITAL KILLINGS
Somalia News Update (Uppsala, September 24) - The three Indian
doctors killed in the Baydhabo hospital by an exploding grenade on
August 31, died when they tried to remove a grenade they had found
inside the hospital. This remarkable new story about the tragic
deaths at the hospital was presented to SNU's reporter by the local
police investigator - who like all southern Somali police is salaried
by UNOSOM. Complaining to SNU's reporter that one of the major
problem of the police is that their word does not count, he claimed
the story had been confirmed by the fourth doctor present at the
occasion. This doctor had survived the accident and was now being
treated at a Nairobi hospital. SNU's reporter was subsequently able
to obtain a confirmation of the story from the local UNOSOM
headquarters.
FROM TRANQUILLITY TO FIGHTING: THE SAD OUTCOME OF THE SSDF CONGRESS
Somalia News Update (Bosaaso/Uppsala, September 28) - Two persons
were shot dead in Bosaaso during the weekend in a confrontation
between groups loyal to the two person claiming chairmanship of the
SSDF - Colonel Abdullahi Yusuf and General Mohamed Abshir Muse.
Following former Somali Prime Minister Abdirizak Haji Huseen's
turning down of the appointment of himself as a new chairman, a
"Supreme Committee" of the SSDF is claimed to have reelected Abshir
as chairman. That claim is contested by Abdullahi Yusuf who claims to
have been elected by the congress delegates on August 25.
The Northeast has throughout the Somali civil war remained
stable and, with the exception of the clash with the Islamist groups
in early 1992, the area has been spared from fighting. However, with
the advent of the SSDF congress tensions in the are rose during the
summer. The mounting political tensions have also been coupled with a
rise in banditry and kidnappings.
REVIEW OF MOHAMED SAHNOUN'S BOOK
By Abdul Abdi
Mohamed Sahnoun. Somalia: The Missed Opportunities. The United
States Institute of Peace Press, Washington, D.C., US$ 8.95, 89
pages, 1994.
Those want to buy Mohamed Sahnoun's new book in order to
understand recent United Nations blunders in Somalia ought to
keep their money. However, those who want to know if the UN could
have saved Somalia - long before 300,000 Somalis starved to death
- ought to buy and read this book.
Sahnoun, a veteran Algerian diplomat, was UN Secretary
General Boutros Boutros-Ghali's first special representative in
Somalia. He resigned from this post after his boss reprimanded
him for publicly criticizing the inept UN bureaucracy and for
participating in a meeting before consulting New York. Shortly
after, Sahnoun volunteered to become his former boss's special
envoy to Somalia but it was an offer that Boutros-Ghali could
afford to refuse.
In Sahnoun's view, the UN missed three opportunities to save
Somalia before the state collapsed and the warlords, the
technicals and the NGOs took charge.
The first opportunity, says Sahnoun, presented itself during
the 1988 civil war when dictator Siyad Barre bombed cities in the
north-western region (now the self-proclaimed Somaliland
Republic). Sahnoun argues the UN should have mediated between
Siyad's regime and the secessionist SNM movement.
The second opportunity, observes Sahnoun, was available in
1990 when Siyad arrested members of the Manifesto Group (a
coalition of Somali statesmen, intellectuals and businessmen) who
signed a letter that called for Siyad's resignation and for
democratic elections. Sahnoun argues the UN should have forced
Siyad to release these political prisoners and to restore the
democracy that existed on the eve of his revolution in 1969.
And the third opportunity, notes Sahnoun, was there to be
exploited in 1991 shortly after Siyad fled the presidential
palace. Instead of evacuating its staff and refusing to get
involved in Somalia's internal affairs, Sahnoun maintains the UN
should have forced the victorious Hawiye to share power with the
defeated Daarood.
Having followed Sahnoun's arguments and the political
developments in Somalia, I remain unconvinced that these so-
called opportunities ever existed at all. With or without UN
mediation, the SNM leadership was committed to secession and
wasn't ready for any sort of dialogue short of unconditional
break-up with the south. No matter what kind of leverage the UN
had on Siyad, he repeatedly said that he came to power through
the barrel of the gun and that was the only way he would ever go.
And no matter how hard the UN tried, it would never have
convinced the USC forces that chased Siyad out of Mogadishu to
share power with Siyad's supporters.
Sahnoun's views about these supposedly missed opportunities,
I am afraid, are based on his misunderstanding of the Somali mind
and his misreading of Somali tribal politics. For instance, in
the Somali mind, the political pie is either won or lost but
never shared. He also fails to comprehend the depth of distrust
and dislike between the Hawiye and the Daarood and between the
Isaaq and the Daarood.
In addition, Sahnoun exceedingly over-estimates the power of
the UN to resolve ancient tribal conflicts in Africa. As Saadia
Touval notes in the current (Sept./Oct.) issue of FOREIGN
AFFAIRS, "the United Nations has great difficulty performing many
basic functions required of an effective mediator. It does not
serve well as an authoritative channel of communication. It has
little real political leverage. Its promises and threats lack
credibility. And it is incapable of pursuing coherent, flexible,
and dynamic negotiations guided by an effective strategy."
Sahnoun missed a real opportunity to write a decent book
about the origins of the Somali conflict, the comprehensive
international response and the mistakes of both the UN and the US
Perhaps some historian, such as I.M. Lewis, or a journalist will
have to write that book. I certainly look forward to it.
(Abdul Abdi, a Somali-American, is a former staff member of the
Somali Service of the Voice America and is presently a free-lance
journalist in Washington, D.C.)
____________________________________________________________________
SNU is an entirely independent newsletter devoted to critical
analysis of the political and humanitarian developments in Somalia
and Somaliland. SNU is edited and published by Dr. Bernhard Helander,
Uppsala University, Sweden. SNU is produced with support from the
Scandinavian Institute of African Studies, Uppsala, Sweden.
____________________________________________________________________
