| Return Create A Forum - Home | |
| --------------------------------------------------------- | |
| True Left | |
| https://trueleft.createaforum.com | |
| --------------------------------------------------------- | |
| ***************************************************** | |
| Return to: Issues | |
| ***************************************************** | |
| #Post#: 2-------------------------------------------------- | |
| Statue decolonization | |
| By: 90sRetroFan Date: June 29, 2020, 11:52 pm | |
| --------------------------------------------------------- | |
| [img width=1280 | |
| height=1168] | |
| https://xyz.net.au/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/IMG_9029.jpeg[/img] | |
| OLD CONTENT: | |
| The recently ongoing movement to remove colonialist statues | |
| started with the Rhodes Must Fall campaign: | |
| en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhodes_Must_Fall | |
| [quote]Rhodes Must Fall (#RhodesMustFall) was a protest movement | |
| that began on 9 March 2015, originally directed against a statue | |
| at the University of Cape Town (UCT) that commemorates Cecil | |
| Rhodes. The campaign for the statue's removal received global | |
| attention[2][3] and led to a wider movement to "decolonise" | |
| education across South Africa.[3][4] On 9 April2015, following a | |
| UCT Council vote the previous night, the statue was removed. | |
| Rhodes Must Fall captured national headlines throughout 2015 and | |
| sharply divided public opinion in South Africa. It also inspired | |
| the emergence of allied student movements at other universities, | |
| both within South Africa and elsewhere in the world.[/quote] | |
| then in the US acquired an understandable emphasis on removing | |
| Confederate monuments: | |
| en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Removal_of_Confederate_monuments_and_memor | |
| ials | |
| [quote]In the wake of the Charleston church shooting in June | |
| 2015, several municipalities in the United States removed | |
| monuments and memorials on public property dedicated to the | |
| Confederate States of America. The momentum accelerated in | |
| August 2017 after the Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville, | |
| Virginia.[1][2][3] The removals were driven by the belief that | |
| the monuments glorify white supremacy and memorialize a | |
| government whose founding principle was the perpetuation and | |
| expansion of slavery.[4][5][6][7][8] Many of those who object to | |
| the removals, like President Trump, claim that the artifacts are | |
| part of the cultural heritage of the United States.[9][/quote] | |
| though also including some other statues: | |
| hyperallergic.com/430694/san-francisco-racist-statute/ | |
| but elsewhere retains its primarily anti-colonialist focus: | |
| www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/aug/22/toppling-statues-n | |
| elsons-column-should-be-next-slavery | |
| www.ft.com/content/7ae28cf4-8e09-11e7-a352-e46f43c5825d | |
| www.theguardian.com/world/2018/feb/06/canada-halifax-statue-edwa | |
| rd-cornwallis | |
| www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/10/02/captain-cook-statue-removed- | |
| new-zealand-mountain-maori-protests/ | |
| The most common rightist criticism of this movement is to accuse | |
| it of being an attempt to somehow "erase history", which is of | |
| course nonsense. Far from wanting to erase history, we are | |
| positively generating public interest in history by revisiting | |
| who built the statues, what the statues mean to their builders, | |
| why they deserve to beremoved, and indeed why it took so long | |
| for calls for their removal to begin. We are certainly not | |
| trying to make people forget the existence of the historical | |
| figures portrayed by the statues. If we were, we wouldalso be | |
| trying to ban teaching of colonial history, which not even | |
| rightists accuse us of (in fact they tend to accuse us of the | |
| opposite: of excessively promoting the teaching of colonial | |
| history!). No, a statue of a historical figure represents | |
| celebration or veneration of that figure. That is what we are | |
| opposed to: a colonialist statue still standing in a supposedly | |
| post-colonial country implies that the country has not yet | |
| really been decolonized, at least not in spirit. The truth is | |
| that rightists to this day remain proud of the colonial era, | |
| which iswhy they are defending their statues. Some are honest | |
| enough to admit this, others are not, but these two groups stand | |
| together in defending their statues. | |
| What makes the rightist position all the more absurd is that | |
| many of these rightists claim to be "nationalists". By defending | |
| colonialist statues, they prove they are anything but. | |
| Nationalism is anti-colonialism. We who call for the removal of | |
| colonialist statues are the true nationalists, and we should be | |
| proudly taking back this label (among others): | |
| en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhodes_Must_Fall#Supporting_student_who_ma | |
| de_Pro-Hitler_and_anti-Semitic_remarks | |
| [quote]On 25 April 2015, Mcebo Dlamini, then president of the | |
| Students� Representative Council (SRC) of Wits University (a | |
| South African public research university), stated in a Facebook | |
| post that he �loves Adolf Hitler� � Dlamini later declared | |
| during a radio interview on PowerFM that �Jews are devils,� a | |
| remark which led the South African Jewish Board of Deputies to | |
| lay criminal charges of hate speech against him.[/quote] | |
| Nevertheless, I suggest that in order to sidestep the rightist | |
| invective as efficiently as possible, we could consider (as an | |
| alternative to removing entire statues) just decapitating each | |
| statue and displaying the disembodied head hanging adjacent to | |
| the rest of the statue. This would visually prove beyond any | |
| doubt that we are not trying to make people think that the | |
| colonialists (and, by inference, the colonial era)never existed, | |
| but merely declaring what we think of colonialists. | |
| As for the issue of legality, the basic line of reasoning is | |
| adequately covered as follows: | |
| www.dailytarheel.com/article/2018/10/maya-little-trial-1021 | |
| [quote]Holmes tried to build a case that Little�s actions � | |
| dousing the statue and its pedestal in red paint and her blood � | |
| were justified under the necessity defense, which asserts that | |
| citizens can violate laws that contradict the big-picture wishes | |
| of the Constitution. | |
| �In our history, people have had to commit crimes in order to | |
| raise the issues,� Holmes said. �Because the laws and the | |
| government�s complicity in racism has required them to break the | |
| law.� | |
| Holmes linked Little�s case to that of the Friendship Nine, a | |
| group of black men who were arrested for staging a sit-in at a | |
| segregated lunch counter in South Carolina in 1961. | |
| �It sometimes becomes necessary to breaksome sort of technical | |
| minor law in order to vindicate the broader values of the | |
| Constitution,� Holmes said. | |
| In 2015, the FriendshipNine's convictions were ceremoniously | |
| overturned. At court, the judge � the nephew of the judge who | |
| originally sentenced the group � said, "We cannot rewrite | |
| history, but we can right history.� | |
| Holmes said henoted comparisons in the cases to argue that | |
| Little�s charges were the same sort of situation, civil | |
| disobedience that would be considered favorably in the eyes of | |
| history, like the illegal assistance northerners gave to slaves | |
| on the Underground Railroad, a violation of the Fugitive Slave | |
| Act. | |
| The Equal Protection Clause has also beencited in lawsuits | |
| pertaining to courthouses� display of the Confederateflag, but | |
| those cases were civil whereas Little�s was criminal. The | |
| combination of the necessity defense in conjunction with the | |
| Equal Protection violation is new, Holmes said.[/quote] | |
| Please use this topic not only to discuss the issue, but to post | |
| news updates on particular statue removal campaigns, and to | |
| point out currently untargeted statues that you would like to | |
| see removed. If we could eventually build up full lists of | |
| colonialist statues in every country, that would be awesome. | |
| ... | |
| Here is a good one: | |
| www.post-gazette.com/news/nation/2018/10/18/The-Stone-Mountain-c | |
| arving-plays-a-complicated-role-in-the-race-for-Georgia-governor | |
| /stories/201810180211 | |
| [quote]Stacey Abrams, a Democrat and former State House minority | |
| leader, is the firstblack woman in the country to win a major | |
| party�s nomination for governor, and it was Ms. Abrams, 44, who | |
| injected Stone Mountain into the contest. | |
| ... | |
| In a flurry of posts on Twitter, Ms. Abrams declared the Stone | |
| Mountain carving �a blight on our state,� and called for it to | |
| be removed. | |
| ... | |
| her Republican opponent, Brian Kemp, haschosen a different | |
| focus, winning his party�s primary with a series of provocative | |
| ads in which he brandished a shotgun and said he might use his | |
| own pickup truck to deport �criminal illegals.� | |
| Mr. Kemp, who is white, has, like President Donald Trump, | |
| denounced the movement to take down Confederate monuments. In | |
| July, as the Atlanta NAACP planned aprotest calling for the | |
| removal of the Stone Mountain carving, Mr. Kempsaid on Facebook | |
| that he would protect it from �the radical left.� | |
| ... | |
| The idea to carve the side of the mountain was hatched in 1914. | |
| The next year, the Klan, which had faded after first emerging | |
| during Reconstruction, was revived atop the mountain with a | |
| cross burning. | |
| Proponents of the carving had strong Klan ties, with one early | |
| booster, Helen Plane, even suggesting that Klansmen be included | |
| in the carving. The group, she wrote, �saved us from Negro | |
| domination and carpetbag rule.� | |
| The carving effort stalled during the Great Depression, but in | |
| 1954, MarvinGriffin, a candidate for governor, stumped on a | |
| promise to uphold segregation in the wake of the Brown v. Board | |
| of Education ruling � and to finish the carving. | |
| After Mr. Griffin�s election, the state bought the land in 1958, | |
| writing into law that it was meant to be operated as a | |
| �perpetual memorial� to the Confederacy.[/quote] | |
| This is what the carving looks like: | |
| [img width=1280 | |
| height=853] | |
| https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/72/Stone_Mountain%2C_the_carvi… | |
| Cananyone seriously deny that the mountainside would have looked | |
| infinitely better if left untouched? What, then, does this say | |
| about theaesthetic sense of those responsible for this overt | |
| vandalism? The Stone Mountain carving is a symbolic microcosm of | |
| Western civilization, whose very existence is a form of | |
| continuous rudeness and disrespect towards everything around it. | |
| Removing the carving now, of course, will not restore the | |
| mountainside to what it used to be before the carving was made, | |
| and so be it. Let the indelible scar on the stone stand as a | |
| brutally honest reminder of the blight upon the world that | |
| Western civilization has been. Nevertheless, erasing the carving | |
| itself will at least show that we have had enough of tolerating | |
| its hubris in thinking that its existence actually improved the | |
| world when it could not be moreaesthetically clear that nothing | |
| could be further from the truth. | |
| (Offtopic, here is an example of how to make mountainsides look | |
| better: | |
| agrifarmingtips.com/terrace-step-farming-inca-advantages-and-dis | |
| advantages/ | |
| ) | |
| --- | |
| www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-6462695/Mayor-removes-highly-va | |
| luable-Gainsborough-painting-office-links-slave-trade.html | |
| [quote]Cleo Lake took down the 'dull and dated' portrait of Lord | |
| Nugent from the walls of City Hall in Bristol. | |
| Paintedby the artist Thomas Gainsborough, the portrait shows | |
| Lord Nugent holding a copy of the 1750 Act for the Regulation of | |
| the Slave Trade, which he helped pass through parliament. | |
| ... | |
| Earlier this year, the Mayor took down a portrait of the Bristol | |
| slave trader Edward Colston, whose ships transported nearly | |
| 100,000 Africans to the Americas.[/quote] | |
| And as always we get to learn a bit more about history in the | |
| process: | |
| [quote]WHAT WERE LORD NUGENT'S LINKS TO THE SLAVE TRADE? | |
| The politician Robert Craggs Nugent (1709-1788) represented | |
| Bristol in the House of Commons from 1754 until 1774. | |
| By 1782, he had become the longest continually-serving member of | |
| the Commons, and so became the Father of the House. | |
| He was involved in the 1750 Act of Parliament. | |
| The1750 Act dissolved the Royal Africa Company and transferred | |
| its assets to the African Company of Merchants - the slave | |
| trading posts that existed in what is now Ghana. | |
| This was an important step in turning the transatlantic slave | |
| trade from a lucrative one for Bristol merchants into a trade | |
| that took place on an industrial scale.[/quote] | |
| [quote]Edward Colston: Bristol's beloved son and wealthy slave | |
| trader | |
| Edward Colston was born to a wealthy merchant family in Bristol, | |
| 1636. | |
| After working as an apprentice at a livery company he began to | |
| explore the shipping industry and started up his own business. | |
| He later joined the Royal African Company and rose up the ranks | |
| to Deputy Governor. | |
| TheCompany had complete control of Britain's slave trade, as | |
| well as its gold and Ivory business, with Africa and the forts | |
| on the coast of west Africa. | |
| During his tenure at the Company his ships transported around | |
| 80,000 slaves from Africa to the Caribbean and America. | |
| Around 20,000 of them, including around 3,000 or more children, | |
| died during the journeys. | |
| ... | |
| Aa statue commemorating Colston in Bristol, a plaque reads: | |
| 'Erected by citizens of Bristol as a memorial of one of the most | |
| virtuous and wise sons of their city.' | |
| There are at least 20 roads, schools, pubs, businesses and | |
| buildings named after Edward Colston, and the slave trader is | |
| still commemorated and celebrated in the city.[/quote] | |
| WE WILL REPLACE YOU! | |
| --- | |
| www.independent.co.uk/voices/poll-shows-brits-are-proud-of-colon | |
| ialism-clearly-they-havent-heard-of-these-colonial-crimes-a68231 | |
| 51.html | |
| [quote]When we are taught about Empire we are rarely given the | |
| gruesome details that counter the idea of Britain being a | |
| benevolent Imperial power. Thisis partly due to a whitewashing | |
| of history curriculums. This was only exacerbated by attempts | |
| from Michael Gove to turn the history syllabus into nationalist | |
| propaganda. To add to this views put forward by pop historians | |
| such as Andrew Roberts serve to glorify Empire. | |
| ... | |
| David Cameron ruled out apologizing for the slave trade and the | |
| Amritsar massacre. This is in spite of the fact that Cameron and | |
| his wife have ancestral links to the slave trade.[/quote] | |
| The more statues pulled down, the more chances to raise | |
| awareness of history. It is happening, even if slowly: | |
| www.theguardian.com/world/2018/dec/14/racist-gandhi-statue-remov | |
| ed-from-university-of-ghana | |
| [quote]Students at the university welcomed the decision to | |
| remove the statue. �It�s a massive win for all Ghanaians because | |
| it was constantly reminding us of how inferior we are,� Benjamin | |
| Mensah told Agence France-Presse. | |
| The head of language, literature and drama at the Institute of | |
| African Studies, Obadele Kambon, said the removal was an issue | |
| of �self-respect�. | |
| �If we show that we have no respect for ourselvesand look down | |
| on our own heroes and praise others who had no respect for us, | |
| then there is an issue,� he said. | |
| �If we indeed don�t show any self-respect for our heroes, how | |
| can the world respect us? Thisis victory for black dignity and | |
| self-respect. The campaign has paid off.�[/quote] | |
| --- | |
| One McKinley statue down: | |
| www.times-standard.com/2019/02/28/mckinley-statue-removed-from-a | |
| rcata-plaza/ | |
| Good job! | |
| en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_McKinley#Peace_and_territorial_gai | |
| n | |
| [quote]McKinleyalso pursued the annexation of the Republic of | |
| Hawaii. The new republic, dominated by business interests, had | |
| overthrown the Queen in 1893 when she rejected a limited role | |
| for herself.[159] ... McKinley biographer H. Wayne Morgan notes, | |
| "McKinley was the guiding spirit behind the annexation of | |
| Hawaii, showing ... a firmness in pursuing it";[162] the | |
| President told Cortel, "We need Hawaii just as much and a good | |
| deal more than we did California. It is manifest | |
| destiny."[163][/quote] | |
| --- | |
| As you may know, Portugal has a verylong history of colonialism, | |
| and a history of being very proud of it. In the 1940s, during | |
| the nationalist dictatorship of the Estado Novo, they erected a | |
| "Monument to the Discoveries" (Padr�o dos Descobrimentos): | |
| This disgusting 52-meter-high colossus celebrates the main | |
| figures associated with Portuguese colonialism. The square right | |
| in front of it has a similarly colossal compass rose and a world | |
| map, gifts of none other than Apartheid South Africa. | |
| In a country such as this, public talks of decolonization are | |
| almost non-existent. But there are things in the works, and I | |
| mentioned that monument for this recent exhibition about Africa | |
| being held in it: | |
| www.padraodosdescobrimentos.pt/pt/evento/visita-conversada-com-2 | |
| / | |
| The significance of such a thing being held in that specific | |
| monument should not be lost on us. | |
| --- | |
| globalnews.ca/news/5081694/sir-john-a-macdonald-statue-vandalize | |
| d-once-again-in-downtown-montreal/ | |
| [quote]Activists calling themselves #MacdonaldMustFall group | |
| claimed responsibility, saying the vandalism comes on the | |
| International Day for the Elimination of Racial Discrimination | |
| promulgated by the United Nations and was done in solidarity | |
| with other worldwide actions against racism.[/quote] | |
| Keep the pressure on! | |
| theconversation.com/john-a-macdonald-should-not-be-forgotten-nor | |
| -celebrated-101503 | |
| [quote]even by historical standards, a story by Rachel D�coste | |
| in the Huffington Post shows that Macdonald was �way more racist | |
| than his contemporaries.� | |
| ... | |
| while Macdonald was prime minister, the M�tis were attacked | |
| twice, the Canadian army led an unprovoked attack against Chief | |
| Poundmaker�s people, many First Nations and M�tis leaders were | |
| jailed (with a number of them dying in jail or shortly after | |
| they were released), Louis Riel was hanged for treason even | |
| though he was an American citizen, the largest mass execution in | |
| Canadian history occurred with the hanging of eight Cree and | |
| Assiniboine men in North Battleford, Sask. The Indian Actwas | |
| amended and became much more oppressive and punitive and a | |
| starvation policy was implemented.[/quote] | |
| Further reading: | |
| rabble.ca/blogs/bloggers/jesse/2015/01/10-crimes-john-macdonald | |
| www.thestar.com/opinion/commentary/2014/01/13/should_we_really_b | |
| e_celebrating_sir_john_a_macdonalds_birthday.html | |
| --- | |
| www.baltimoresun.com/news/maryland/baltimore-county/bs-md-hostil | |
| e-indians-sign-20190430-story.html | |
| [quote]A historical marker at Fort Garrison in Stevenson has | |
| been removed after officials received a complaint regarding its | |
| use of the term �hostile Indians.� | |
| ... | |
| It is indicative of weighted language and bias that some | |
| Americans have toward Native American history, Harley said, and | |
| no trepresentative of the fact that the original colonists | |
| forcibly displaced the native population, mostly through | |
| violence and force. | |
| ... | |
| the bishop brushed aside the idea of preserving the marker�s | |
| historical significance, even in the sense that it represents a | |
| period of time in which these sentiments were more widely | |
| accepted. | |
| In response, he quoted a West African proverb that says, �The | |
| lion�s story will never be known as long as the hunter is the | |
| one to tell it.�[/quote] | |
| (Next, Israel will talk about "hostile Palestinians".....) | |
| #Post#: 4-------------------------------------------------- | |
| Re: Statue decolonization | |
| By: 90sRetroFan Date: June 30, 2020, 12:17 am | |
| --------------------------------------------------------- | |
| OLD CONTENT contd. | |
| Going hand in hand with removal of colonialist monuments is | |
| building of anti-colonialist monuments: | |
| www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-london-48724128 | |
| [quote]A monument honouring the "tremendous contribution" of the | |
| Windrush generation is to be erected in London. | |
| ... | |
| Events are taking place across the country on Saturday to mark | |
| the first National Windrush Day. | |
| ... | |
| BaronessFloella Benjamin, chair of the Windrush Commemoration | |
| Committee, said: "Having a Windrush monument located at Waterloo | |
| Station where thousands of Windrush pioneers - including | |
| children like myself - first arrived inLondon, will be a | |
| symbolic link to our past as we celebrate our future." | |
| Janice Irwin, from community group Ageless Teenagers, described | |
| the plans as "fantastic", but also "long overdue", and said | |
| itwas "a little strange" that it would be built at Waterloo | |
| Station, and not Brixton where many people from the Windrush | |
| generation settled. | |
| Some of the Windrush generation were wrongly told after they had | |
| lived in the UK for decades they were in the country illegally. | |
| Many lost their right to work or get NHS treatment, while others | |
| were detained or deported. | |
| Thethen Home Secretary Amber Rudd apologised last year for the | |
| deportationthreats, calling the scandal "wrong" and "appalling". | |
| An estimated 500,000 people now living in the UK have been | |
| called the Windrush generation. | |
| TheHMT Empire Windrush first arrived at Tilbury Docks, Essex, on | |
| 22 June 1948, bringing workers from Jamaica, Trinidad and Tobago | |
| and other islands, as a response to post-war labour shortages in | |
| the UK.[/quote] | |
| www.abc.net.au/news/2019-07-08/sydney-statues-of-colonial-leader | |
| s-in-spotlight-again/11285380 | |
| [quote]There are 25 publicly funded statues of the colony's | |
| early leaders around the CBD. | |
| Amongthem are Captain Cook, Governor Arthur Phillip, Lachlan | |
| Macquarie, Queen Victoria, explorer Matthew Flinders and even | |
| his cat Trim. | |
| ... | |
| "It'sbreathtakingly hard trying to feel proud walking around | |
| seeing statues of people that my old people have told me have | |
| declared martial law on us."[/quote] | |
| So far so good. But then: | |
| [quote]Mr Moran said a statue of a prominent Indigenous leader | |
| would be a small but significant step towards | |
| reconciliation.[/quote] | |
| It's the colonialist statues that have to be taken down,not | |
| merely other statues added. No non-colonialist statues should be | |
| built before the last colonialist statue has been removed, in | |
| the same way that we lower the colonial flag prior to raising | |
| our own flag. Otherwise subjects the non-colonialist symbol to | |
| the indignity of sharing space with the colonialist symbol. | |
| --- | |
| Medals count as statues: | |
| rapidcityjournal.com/news/local/bill-seeks-to-remove-stain-of-wo | |
| unded-knee-massacre-medals/article_ef12b305-8252-5f80-8541-7f3cf | |
| d015c2d.html | |
| [quote]Newfederal legislation seeks to �Remove the Stain� from | |
| the Medal of Honorby rescinding 20 medals that were awarded to | |
| soldiers who participated in the 1890 Wounded Knee Massacre. | |
| ... | |
| The massacre happened on Dec. 29, 1890, near Wounded Knee Creek | |
| on the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation in southwestern South | |
| Dakota. A force of 490 U.S. soldiers � armed with rapid-fire, | |
| wheel-mounted artillery guns � was attempting todisarm a camp of | |
| about 370 Lakota Sioux people when a shot rang out andchaotic | |
| firing ensued. | |
| A total of 31 soldiers died during the encounter or afterward | |
| from their wounds, compared to hundreds of NativeAmericans. | |
| Although precise estimates of Native American deaths vary, the | |
| Remove the Stain Act says there were 350 to 375 Native American | |
| fatalities, nearly two-thirds of whom were unarmed women and | |
| children. | |
| ... | |
| Afterthe massacre, some of the Native American dead were left on | |
| the frozen ground for several days before a military-led burial | |
| party dumped the bodies in a mass grave. Today, that grave is | |
| marked by a small, weathered monument that was erected in 1903. | |
| The Army awarded 20 Medals of Honor � the nation�s highest | |
| military award � to soldiers who participated in the massacre. | |
| ... | |
| Thelegislation, if passed by Congress and signed by the | |
| president, would require the names of the 20 medal winners to be | |
| removed from the government�s official Medal of Honor Roll. | |
| ... | |
| The findings in thenew legislation also mention the historical | |
| writings and statements of Maj. Gen. Nelson Miles, who was not | |
| present at the massacre but commanded all of the Army�s | |
| departments west of the Mississippi River atthe time. | |
| Drawing from a letter Miles wrote in 1891, the legislation | |
| quotes him stating, �I have never heard of a more brutal, | |
| cold-blooded massacre than that at Wounded Knee.�[/quote] | |
| Western civilization itself is a stain on the New World that | |
| needs removing. | |
| (Notonly should the medals be rescinded, but all known | |
| descendants of the soldiers who participated in the massacre | |
| should be prohibited by the state from reproducing.) | |
| --- | |
| https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4RIXrfz2x1E | |
| Visitor comment: I agree with most of what he's saying, only the | |
| notion that people who never owned slaves should pay | |
| "reparations" to people who never were slaves, in apology for | |
| slavery existing - something that no one today was even alive to | |
| see - is retarded. I thinka much better course of action, one | |
| that won't actually deepen ethnic division, is to remove these | |
| monuments and to shift the cultural forces of the US towards | |
| Univeralism rather than tribalism. | |
| 90sRF response: He wasn't necessarily demanding reparations, but | |
| rather pointing out that the same people unwilling to pay | |
| reparations gladly pay for stuff to celebrate historical slave | |
| owners. If people who had nothing to do with slavery themselves | |
| solely cared about keeping their own money, they shouldn't be | |
| willing to pay for either. Unwillingness to pay only for the | |
| former can therefore be deduced to be caused by something other | |
| than merely people who had nothing to do with slavery wanting to | |
| keep their own money. | |
| --- | |
| https://summit.new | |
| s/2019/07/25/video-algerians-tear-down-statue-of-general-de-gaul | |
| le-in-france/ | |
| --- | |
| People are catching on to our way of thinking: | |
| www.campusreform.org/?ID=13537 | |
| [quote]Aimedat UVA President James Ryan, the petition entitled | |
| "Remove Monument to Genocide that Welcomes People to UVA," as | |
| reported by Newsweek, calls for UVA to scrap a statue of George | |
| Rogers Clark, a leader of the Lewis and Clark Expedition and | |
| brother of William Clark. The petition has received 450 total | |
| signatures, just 50 signatures shy of its final goal,at | |
| publication time. | |
| Inscribed text underneath the statue reads �George Rogers Clark: | |
| Conqueror of the Northwest.� | |
| �Remove the statue of George Rogers Clark engaged in genocide to | |
| a museum where it can be presented as a shameful memory,� the | |
| petition demands. �The statue of George Rogers Clark at UVA | |
| depictsa white man on a horse dressed for war�.He has other men | |
| behind him with a gun and a barrel of gun powder, and he appears | |
| to be reaching back for a gun with his right hand. There are | |
| four Native Americans in front of him, including one infant.� | |
| ... | |
| Richard Handler, an anthropology professor at UVA, told the | |
| Cavalier Daily that the statue could be moved to an exhibit to | |
| teach people about genocidal behavior against Native Americans. | |
| �People need to realize that statues were not handed down from | |
| God but are human creations of specific times,places and | |
| peoples,� Handler said. �As our thinking changes, there�s | |
| absolutely nothing wrong with removing, destroying, or even | |
| rededicatinga statue.�[/quote] | |
| --- | |
| Another history lesson: | |
| www.startribune.com/the-real-history-of-mount-rushmore/388715411 | |
| / | |
| [quote]Thecarved visages are iconic Americana, appearing in a | |
| gazillion media photos and books and travel features, in | |
| advertisements and promotions, on U.S. postage stamps in two | |
| eras, and on South Dakota�s license plate (�Great Faces. Great | |
| Places.�). | |
| But the back story of Mount Rushmore is hardly a rich history of | |
| a shared democratic ideal. Some seethe monument in the Black | |
| Hills as one of the spoils of violent conquest over indigenous | |
| tribes by a U.S. Army clearing the way for white settlers driven | |
| westward by a lust for land and gold.[/quote] | |
| Actually, violent conquest of minorities by the majority is the | |
| democratic ideal. | |
| [quote]As it was in colonial America, the young country�s | |
| expansion was fueled by �Manifest Destiny� � a self-supreme | |
| notion that any land coveted by Euro-Americans was, by | |
| providence, rightfully theirs for the taking. | |
| ... | |
| Thesculptures were chiseled by an imported Ku Klux Klansman on a | |
| granite mountain owned by indigenous tribes on what they | |
| considered sacred land � land that the U.S. Supreme Court said | |
| in 1980 was illegally taken from them. | |
| ... | |
| Theso-called �Indian wars� featured the U.S. Army aggressively | |
| enforcing America�s expansionist resolve by exterminating | |
| indigenous tribes who sought to stay where they�d always been. | |
| Indians would lose nearly everybloody battle that would follow. | |
| ... | |
| the Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868 granting Lakota autonomy over a | |
| broad, 60-million-acre region encompassing all of South Dakota | |
| west of the Missouri River � including the Black Hills � and | |
| parts of North Dakota and Nebraska. | |
| ... | |
| But like every tribal treaty before and since, the U.S. reneged | |
| on its Fort Laramie promises almost immediately by failing to | |
| prevent small-scale incursions into �The Great Sioux | |
| Reservation.� | |
| Justsix years after Laramie, Gen. George Custer led a U.S. Army | |
| expedition out of Fort Lincoln (present-day Bismarck, N.D.) into | |
| the Black Hills toexplore suitable sites for forts and routes to | |
| them. The action was a purposely provocative treaty violation. | |
| Anothermission, to assess the presence of gold, would hasten the | |
| treaty�s demise. Custer rosily trumpeted that gold was found, | |
| unleashing a torrent of prospectors that the U.S. chose not to | |
| contain. | |
| After a failed bid to buy the Black Hills, the U.S. determined | |
| to drive out the Lakota and simply take the area�s riches.Fierce | |
| resistance by Crazy Horse and Sitting Bull was worn down by the | |
| Army�s big guns and well-supplied legions, mostly dispatched | |
| from Minnesota�s Fort Snelling. | |
| ... | |
| Atwar�s end, the �victorious� U.S. carved up the Great Sioux | |
| Reservation by first taking back the Black Hills and broad | |
| swaths of buffers. The Lakota were forced onto mostly useless | |
| land, including the Pine Ridge Reservation on South Dakota�s | |
| southern border. | |
| ... | |
| On a bitter December day in 1890, a U.S. cavalry contingent | |
| intercepted a band of ghost-dancing Lakota and attempted to | |
| confiscate what few guns they had. A shot rang out, and panicked | |
| soldiers opened fire from all sides, killing150 men, women and | |
| children before hunting down scores of unarmed Lakota and | |
| shooting them point-blank as they struggled in the snow. | |
| The infamous Wounded Knee Massacre (incredibly, the U.S. called | |
| it a �battle� and awarded medals to its �heroes�) was the last | |
| of America�s long, violent campaigns to subdue indigenous tribes | |
| all across the continent. | |
| ... | |
| Threedecades after Wounded Knee, in 1923, a South Dakota tourism | |
| agent advanced an idea for several large sculptures in the Black | |
| Hills. He enlisted the support of the renowned Gutzon Borglum, | |
| whose most recent work had been carving Stone Mountain, Ga., a | |
| grand gathering site for a white supremacist group Borglum | |
| belonged to, the Ku Klux Klan. | |
| ... | |
| AtMount Rushmore, you may learn that the sculptures are arranged | |
| for maximum sun exposure, itself a cruel irony: The faces of the | |
| four presidents (white conquerors) peer southeast toward a | |
| reservation housing vanquished Lakota, who mostly live out | |
| forgotten, impoverished lives in the shadow of their sacred Paha | |
| Sapa that, legally, still belong to them.[/quote] | |
| This is called democracy. | |
| The Mount Rushmore sculptures must be destroyed. (They are | |
| extremely ugly anyway, and utterly ruin the entire mountainscape | |
| in the most tasteless way possible. In this sense this perfectly | |
| captures how Western civilization interacts with everything it | |
| encounters. We should certainly keep photos to show students in | |
| a post-Western future.) | |
| --- | |
| https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WbCyh_Eew2c | |
| #Post#: 5-------------------------------------------------- | |
| Re: Statue decolonization | |
| By: 90sRetroFan Date: June 30, 2020, 1:42 am | |
| --------------------------------------------------------- | |
| OLD CONTENT contd. | |
| About time: | |
| news.yahoo.com/long-mexico-icon-spanish-conquistador-040345048.h | |
| tml | |
| [quote]ALBUQUERQUE,N.M. (AP) � The Spanish conquistador is an | |
| image found throughout New Mexico, the most Hispanic state in | |
| the United States. | |
| Depictions of men such as 17th century explorers Don Juan de | |
| O�ate and Don Diego deVargas have long adorned murals and been | |
| honored at commemorations as symbols of the region's Hispanic | |
| heritage. | |
| In recent years, however, the conquistador and all the effigies | |
| connected to it have come under intense criticism. Anew | |
| generation of Native American and Latino activists is demanding | |
| that conquistador imagery and names be removed from seals, | |
| schools and streets. They say the figure's connection to | |
| colonialism and indigenous genocide makes the conquistador | |
| outdated, highlighting the region's changing attitudes about its | |
| colonial past. | |
| Activists convinced organizers of the yearly Santa Fe Fiesta to | |
| abandon "the Entrada" � a recreation of de Vargas recapturing | |
| Santa Fe for the Spanish from Pueblo tribes. Under pressure, | |
| Santa Fe's public school district also announced it would limit | |
| when conquistador reenactors visit. This month, the University | |
| of New Mexico said it's looking for a new design for its | |
| official seal following protests from Native Americans over | |
| concerns about the current seal with a conquistador. | |
| ElenaOrtiz, president of the Santa Fe chapter of The Red Nation, | |
| a Native American advocacy group, said the developments come | |
| after years of activism and public campaigns seeking to change | |
| perceptions about the conquistador. | |
| More needs to be done, she said. | |
| "We still have Don Diego parading around," Ortiz said. "This | |
| symbol of genocide should not be allowed in public schools." | |
| ... | |
| NickEstes, an American Studies professor at the University of | |
| New Mexico and co-founder of The Red Nation, said activists want | |
| state leaders to stop lionizing the region's violent colonial | |
| past and recognize the history of Native Americans. | |
| This fight is worse than the battle over U.S. Civil War-era | |
| Confederate monuments in the American South, he said. | |
| "Atleast there's an acknowledgment of this country's legacy with | |
| slavery,"Estes said. "This country has not acknowledged its | |
| legacy with indigenous genocide."[/quote] | |
| therednation.org/ | |
| (They also support BDS: | |
| therednation.org/2019/09/07/the-liberation-of-palestine-represen | |
| ts-an-alternative-path-for-native-nations/ | |
| ) | |
| --- | |
| Holidays also count as statues: | |
| www.chicagotribune.com/opinion/commentary/ct-opinion-columbus-da | |
| y-indigenous-people-20191011-3qaxw2omv5csfdgumzh727iavm-story.ht | |
| ml | |
| [quote]Commentary: Will Columbus Day give way to Indigenous | |
| Peoples Day? More communities are making the shift. | |
| ... | |
| ColumbusDay is a relatively new federal holiday. In 1892, a | |
| joint congressionalresolution prompted President Benjamin | |
| Harrison to mark the �discovery of America by Columbus,� in part | |
| because of �the devout faith of the discoverer and for the | |
| divine care and guidance which has directed our history and so | |
| abundantly blessed our people.� | |
| Europeans invoked God�s will to impose their will on indigenous | |
| people. So it seemed logical to call on God when establishing a | |
| holiday celebrating that conquest too. | |
| Of course, not all Americans considered themselves blessed in | |
| 1892. That same year, a lynching forced black journalist Ida B. | |
| Wells to flee her hometown of Memphis. And while Ellis Island | |
| had opened in January of that year, welcoming European | |
| immigrants, Congress had already banned Chinese immigration a | |
| decade prior, subjecting Chinese people living in the U.S. to | |
| widespread persecution. | |
| ... | |
| Today,cities with significant native populations, such as | |
| Seattle, Portland and Los Angeles, celebrate either Native | |
| American Day or Indigenous Peoples Day. And states such as | |
| Hawaii, Nevada, Minnesota, Alaska and Maine have also formally | |
| recognized their Native populations with similar holidays. Many | |
| Native governments, including the Cherokee and Osage in | |
| Oklahoma, either don�t observe Columbus Day or have replaced | |
| itwith their own holiday. | |
| ... | |
| While Columbus Day affirms the story of a nation created by | |
| Europeans for Europeans, Indigenous Peoples Day emphasizes | |
| Native histories and Native people � an important addition tothe | |
| country�s ever-evolving understanding of what it means to be | |
| American.[/quote] | |
| https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rMbMJ3DGph4 | |
| --- | |
| https://www.sfexaminer.com/news/columbus-statue-defaced-with-red-paint-near-coi… | |
| --- | |
| More success: | |
| pix11.com/2019/10/14/columbus-park-in-milwaukee-renamed-indigeno | |
| us-peoples-park/ | |
| --- | |
| At least they got our message about Ghandi: | |
| www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/students-call-to-block-manchester-gan | |
| dhi-statue-because-hes-racist-a4262711.html | |
| [quote]The city council approved a 9ft bronze statue of the | |
| Indian independence figure to be erected outside Manchester | |
| Cathedral to promote peace following the 2017 Manchester Arena | |
| terror attack that killed 22 people. | |
| But a group of students are calling for the council to reverse | |
| its decision due to Gandhi�s �well-documented anti-black racism | |
| and complicity in the British Empire's action in Africa". | |
| In an openletter, the students demanded a statement | |
| acknowledging his �racism�, an apology and to reverse the | |
| decision while redirecting funds to commemorate a black | |
| anti-racist activist. | |
| The group says that Gandhi "saw himself as a �fellow-colonist' | |
| ... | |
| It adds: "In 1905, Gandhi appealed to laws asking Indians to | |
| fight againstthe amaZulu, and collected funds to finance the | |
| execution of Black people fighting for self-determination and | |
| the right to their homeland. | |
| "These actions and thoughts are of course not documented in his | |
| autobiography,but they are well documented throughout his | |
| earlier correspondence and writings." | |
| The letter was posted under the hashtag #GandhiMustFall, which | |
| was previously used during efforts to remove a similar statue at | |
| the University of Ghana.[/quote] | |
| --- | |
| www.smh.com.au/national/nsw/sydney-council-set-to-ditch-australi | |
| a-day-celebrations-20191105-p537o5.html | |
| [quote]AustraliaDay celebrations in Sydney's inner west are set | |
| to be scrapped in favour of the Aboriginal festival Yabun under | |
| a council proposal aimed at a "more respectful" approach to the | |
| national holiday. | |
| ... | |
| LaborMayor Darcy Byrne said moving the Australia Day | |
| celebrations at Enmore Park to a different date would stop it | |
| from competing with Yabun and recognise that for Aboriginal | |
| people it is a day of sadness rather than celebration. | |
| "We're seeking to take a more respectful approach toJanuary 26 | |
| and acknowledge that for Aboriginal people it marks the onset of | |
| colonisation, dispossession, the removal of children and the | |
| deliberate destruction of language and culture," Mr Byrne said. | |
| "There'sa growing number of local communities and people across | |
| Australia that think the 26th of January should be a | |
| commemoration not a celebration and the ongoing hurt that | |
| Aboriginal people feel shouldn't be exacerbated through | |
| fireworks and festivals." | |
| ... | |
| The proposal will come before council next Tuesday night and is | |
| likely to pass with the support of Labor councillors and the | |
| Greens.[/quote] | |
| --- | |
| www.theguardian.com/world/2019/nov/05/chile-statues-indigenous-m | |
| apuche-conquistadors | |
| [quote]In the urban centre of Temuco, hooded demonstrators | |
| lassoed a statue of a 16th-century Spanish conquistador last | |
| week and yanked it to the ground. | |
| Cheering bystanders � many wearing the traditional ponchos and | |
| headbands of the indigenous Mapuche people � stamped on the | |
| bronze effigy of Pedro de Valdivia and hammered it with wooden | |
| staffs. | |
| In the city of Concepci�n � which Valdivia found in 1550 � a | |
| crowd toppled another bust of the Spanish coloniser, impaled it | |
| on a spike, and barbecued it at the feet of a statue of his | |
| historical nemesis, the Mapuche chieftain Lautaro. | |
| Inthe nearby town of Collipulli, a bronze of General Cornelio | |
| Saavedra � notorious for leading the bloody 19th-century | |
| �pacification� of the Mapuche heartland � suffered a similar | |
| fate. | |
| Most dramatically of all, a statue in Temuco of the Chilean | |
| military aviator Dagoberto Godoy (1893-1960) was decapitated,and | |
| his head hung from the arm of a statue of the Mapuche warrior | |
| Caupolic�n � now also holding the Mapuche flag, or Wenufoye. | |
| ... | |
| Theattacks on symbols of Spanish colonial rule have provoked a | |
| war of words recalling debates in the US over monuments to | |
| Confederate generals, or in the UK regarding prominent statues | |
| of slavers and imperialists. | |
| Conservative Chilean commentators have branded themacts of | |
| vandalism and the work of �professional agitators�. Others | |
| describe an organic � if overexuberant � desire to challenge | |
| established historical narratives. | |
| �These are actions of a very potent symbolism, in rejecting an | |
| official version that has falsified and grossly airbrushed our | |
| history,� said Pedro Cayuqueo, a Mapuche writer and historian. | |
| �There�s something far deeper going on.� | |
| ... | |
| Such demands are shared by smaller aboriginal groups like the | |
| Diaguita, an Andean desert people with some 90,000 | |
| self-identified descendants. Protesters in the northern city of | |
| La Serena likewise felled and burneda statue of the conquistador | |
| Francisco de Aguirre in late October, replacing it with an image | |
| of �Milanka�, a Diaguita woman.[/quote] | |
| --- | |
| Demographic Blueshift harvest: | |
| news.yahoo.com/democrats-wins-could-help-bring-144259907.html | |
| [quote]RICHMOND,Va. (AP) � An army of Confederate monuments dots | |
| Virginia's landscape but some of those statues could soon start | |
| coming down after Election Day gave Democrats control of the | |
| General Assembly for the first time indecades. | |
| Members of the new legislative majority say they plan to revive | |
| proposals to make it easier to remove the public displays | |
| honoring Civil War soldiers and generals in a state that was | |
| home to twoConfederate capitals. Previous attempts to do so were | |
| quickly dispatched in the Republican-controlled General | |
| Assembly, in votes largely along party lines. | |
| ... | |
| Across the state, officials have catalogued 168 war memorials, | |
| 136 of which are dedicated to Confederate participants in the | |
| Civil War. | |
| ... | |
| Another occasional target of criticism is a statue of prominent | |
| segregationist Harry F. Byrd Sr., a former Virginia governor and | |
| U.S. senator who's considered the architectof the state's | |
| "massive resistance" policy to public school integration. His | |
| figure in bronze stands on the Capitol square.[/quote] | |
| --- | |
| Vegan edition! | |
| au.news.yahoo.com/cambridge-university-removes-painting-after-ve | |
| gans-complain-115638812.html | |
| [quote]A college at Cambridge University in England has removed | |
| a 17th century painting from the wall of its dining hall after | |
| students complained it was putting them off their food. | |
| Hughes Hall reportedly received complaints from vegan students | |
| about The Fowl Market, which shows a collection of dead animals | |
| hanging from hooks. | |
| The painting, by Flemish artist Frans Snyders, was on long-term | |
| loan from the university�s Fitzwilliam Museum but has now been | |
| taken down.[/quote] | |
| --- | |
| Warren is in: | |
| news.yahoo.com/elizabeth-warren-revoking-medals-wounded-knee-mas | |
| sacre-140752378.html | |
| [quote]WASHINGTON― Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) | |
| introduced legislation on Wednesday that would rescind 20 Medals | |
| of Honor awarded to U.S. soldiers who slaughtered hundreds of | |
| Lakota Indians � mostly women and children ― in the | |
| Wounded Knee Massacre of 1890. | |
| Her bill, the Remove the StainAct, is the Senate version of a | |
| bill introduced in the House in June byDemocratic Reps. Denny | |
| Heck (Wash.), Paul Cook (Calif.) and Deb Haaland(N.M.), one of | |
| two Native American women in Congress. | |
| ... | |
| �The horrifying acts of violence against hundreds of Lakota men, | |
| women, and children at Wounded Knee should be condemned, not | |
| celebrated with Medalsof Honor,� Warren said in a statement. | |
| �The Remove the Stain Act acknowledges a profoundly shameful | |
| event in U.S. history, and that�s whyI�m joining my House | |
| colleagues in this effort to advance justice and take a step | |
| toward righting wrongs against Native peoples.�[/quote] | |
| --- | |
| www.foxnews.com/politics/virginias-ralph-northam-pushes-to-remov | |
| e-robert-e-lee-statue-from-us-capitol | |
| [quote]VirginiaGov. Ralph Northam will push for a bill in the | |
| state legislature to replace the state's statue of Confederate | |
| Gen. Robert E. Lee that is displayed in the United States | |
| Capitol building. | |
| The office of the Democratic governor will file a request for a | |
| bill that would outline the process for removing the statue and | |
| selecting a replacement.The figure of Lee is one of two statues | |
| from Virginia in the National Statuary Hall Collection. | |
| The filing come after two Democratic lawmakers requested Northam | |
| replace the statue as part of his legislative agenda for the new | |
| session that begins in February.[/quote] | |
| --- | |
| On a lighter note: | |
| www.yahoo.com/news/comedians-mock-confederate-sympathizer-steve- | |
| 174718631.html | |
| --- | |
| www.washingtontimes.com/news/2020/mar/9/steny-hoyer-wants-roger- | |
| taney-bust-replaced-thurgo/ | |
| [quote]House Democrats said Monday they will try to toss the | |
| bust of former Chief Justice Roger Taney from the collection in | |
| the U.S. Capitol, saying the Maryland jurist�s role in writing | |
| the decision in the 1857 Dred Scott ruling makes him unfit for | |
| that honor. | |
| ... | |
| �We�re entering a new era where we are reexamining our history | |
| and beginning to look at our history for its good. And also its | |
| bad,� Congressional Black Caucus Chairwoman Karen Bass said. | |
| �The removal of Chief Justice Taney�s bust is long overdue in | |
| our nation�s Capitol.� | |
| The Dred Scott decisionconfirmed that the Constitution did not | |
| recognize slaves as U.S. citizens and therefore they could not | |
| sue in federal court. It also declared the Missouri Compromise, | |
| a deal meant to appease escalating tensions over slavery, | |
| unconstitutional, barring Congress from prohibiting slavery in | |
| the western territories. | |
| ... | |
| The push to remove Taney�s bust is part of a larger, national | |
| debate over removing statues and monuments dedicated to | |
| historical figures who are seen as controversial by modern | |
| standards. | |
| In Virginia, the Democratic-led state General Assembly passed | |
| measures over the weekend that rolled back protections for | |
| Confederate monuments and allows local governments to decide | |
| whether or not to remove them.[/quote] | |
| #Post#: 6-------------------------------------------------- | |
| Re: Statue decolonization | |
| By: 90sRetroFan Date: June 30, 2020, 1:59 am | |
| --------------------------------------------------------- | |
| OLD CONTENT contd. | |
| Good job! | |
| www.marketwatch.com/story/confederate-statues-and-monuments-beco | |
| me-targets-in-weekend-protests-of-death-of-black-minneapolis-man | |
| -in-police-custody-2020-05-31 | |
| [quote]RICHMOND,Va. (AP) � Protesters demonstrating against the | |
| death of George Floyd, ablack man who pleaded for air as a white | |
| police officer pressed his knee on his neck, targeted | |
| Confederate monuments in multiple cities. | |
| Astense protests swelled across the country Saturday into Sunday | |
| morning,monuments in Virginia, the Carolinas, Tennessee and | |
| Mississippi were defaced. The presence of Confederate monuments | |
| across the South � and elsewhere in the United States � has been | |
| challenged for years, and someof the monuments targeted were | |
| already under consideration for removal. | |
| Thewords �spiritual genocide� in black spray paint, along with | |
| red handprints, stained the sides of a Confederate monument on | |
| the University of Mississippi campus Saturday, the Oxford Eagle | |
| reported. One person was arrested at the scene. | |
| Ole Miss administrators, student leaders and faculty leaders | |
| have recommended moving the statue � installed in 1906 and a | |
| rallying point in 1962 for people who rioted tooppose the | |
| university�s court-ordered integration � from a central spotto a | |
| Civil War cemetery that�s in a more secluded location on campus, | |
| but the state College Board has delayed action. | |
| Critics have saidits display near the university�s main | |
| administrative building sends a signal that Ole Miss glorifies | |
| the Confederacy and glosses over the South�s history of slavery. | |
| In Charleston, South Carolina, protesters defaced a Confederate | |
| statue near the Battery, a historic area on the coastal city�s | |
| southern tip. The base of the Confederate Defenders statue, | |
| erected in 1932, was spray-painted, including with thewords | |
| �BLM� and �traitors,� news outlets reported. It was later | |
| coveredwith tarp, photos show. | |
| In North Carolina, the base of a Confederate monument at the | |
| State Capitol was marked with a black X and ashorthand for a | |
| phrase expressing contempt for police, according to a photo | |
| posted by a News & Observer journalist to social media. The word | |
| �racist� was also marked on the monument, the newspaper | |
| reported. | |
| ... | |
| Inthe coastal city of Norfolk, protesters climbed a Confederate | |
| monument and spray-painted graffiti on its base, according to | |
| photos posted by a Virginian-Pilot journalist. Norfolk is among | |
| the Virginia cities that have signaled intent to remove their | |
| Confederate monuments. In February,state lawmakers approved | |
| legislation that would give cities autonomy todo so. | |
| A commission in Richmond, the state capital and what was the | |
| capital of the Confederacy, recommended removing one of five | |
| Confederate statues along the city�s famed Monument Avenue. | |
| Photos posted to social media late Saturday and early Sunday | |
| showed the bases of at least two statues � those of Confederate | |
| generals Robert E. Lee and J.E.B. Stuart � almost entirely | |
| covered in graffiti. A statue of Confederate President Jefferson | |
| Davis had �cops ran us over,� spray-painted on the base. A noose | |
| had been flung over Davis� shoulder. | |
| Afire burned for a time at the headquarters of the United | |
| Daughters of the Confederacy, a group responsible for erecting | |
| many Confederate statues and fighting their removal. The | |
| building, too, was covered in graffiti, The Richmond | |
| Times-Dispatch reported. | |
| In Chattanooga, Tenn., protesters spray-painted a statue | |
| Saturday of Confederate Lt. Gen. Alexander P. Stewart on | |
| Saturday, the Chattanooga Times Free Press reported. | |
| In Nashville, Tenn., and in Philadelphia, statues of people | |
| criticized for racist views, but without Confederate ties, were | |
| also targeted. | |
| Protesters in Nashville toppled Saturday a statue of Edward | |
| Carmack, a state lawmaker in the early 1900s and newspaper | |
| publisher who had racist views and wrote editorials lambasting | |
| the writings of prominent Tennessee civil-rights journalist Ida | |
| B. Wells, the Tennessean reported. | |
| Protesters sprayed graffiti on a statue of former Philadelphia | |
| Mayor Frank Rizzo, tried to topple it and set a fire at its | |
| base. Rizzo, mayor from 1972 to 1980, was praised by supporters | |
| as tough on crime but accused by critics of discriminating | |
| against people of color. His 10-foot-tall (3-meter-tall) bronze | |
| statue across from City Hall has been defaced before and is to | |
| be moved next year.[/quote] | |
| --- | |
| Another one down! | |
| www.upi.com/Top_News/US/2020/06/03/Philadelphia-takes-down-statu | |
| e-of-former-Mayor-Frank-Rizzo/4321591190033/ | |
| [quote]"Thestatue is a deplorable monument to racism, bigotry, | |
| and police brutality for members of the Black community," Kenney | |
| said. "The treatment of these communities under Mr. Rizzo's | |
| leadership was among the worst periods in Philadelphia's | |
| history."[/quote] | |
| --- | |
| The list so far: | |
| www.motherjones.com/crime-justice/2020/06/all-the-monuments-to-r | |
| acism-that-have-been-torched-occupied-or-removed/ | |
| And one more: | |
| www.nbcdfw.com/news/local/texas-ranger-statue-at-love-field-remo | |
| ved-over-concerns-about-racist-history/2382528/ | |
| Don't stop now! | |
| --- | |
| www.brusselstimes.com/all-news/belgium-all-news/115251/leopold-i | |
| i-statue-defaced-at-africa-museum/ | |
| [quote]A statue of Leopold II in the garden of the Africa Museum | |
| in Tervuren was defaced, VRT reported Thursday evening. | |
| Other statues of the former Belgian king had already been | |
| vandalized in Halle, Ostend, Ghent and Ekeren. | |
| Thestatue in Ekeren was set on fire on Wednesday night after | |
| having been smeared in red paint last weekend. The bust in Ghent | |
| was also covered inred paint and marked �I can�t breathe,� the | |
| final words of George Floyd, an unarmed black man whose death at | |
| the hands of US police has sparked nationwide uprisings over | |
| police brutality and systemic racism. | |
| [/quote] | |
| www.brusselstimes.com/all-news/belgium-all-news/115178/leopold-i | |
| i-statue-set-on-fire-in-antwerp/ | |
| www.brusselstimes.com/brussels/114713/petition-launched-to-remov | |
| e-statue-of-leopold-ii-in-brussels/ | |
| [quote]As anti-racism protests and demonstrations in honour of | |
| George Floyd, a black man who died after a white police officer | |
| put his knee on his neckfor minutes in the United States last | |
| week, are taking place worldwide,a petition to the City of | |
| Brussels has been launched in Belgium to remove all statues of | |
| Leopold II. | |
| Under his colonial regime, millions of Congolese people died. | |
| Lack of reliable sources have made itdifficult to form an | |
| accurate estimation, but modern estimates range from 1 million | |
| to 15 million. In recent years, a consensus of around 10 million | |
| deaths has been reached among historians. | |
| �Despite all this, Leopold II is commemorated throughout Belgium | |
| through statues, ceremonies in his honour, street names, and so | |
| on. We do not want to erase the past, but we do want to erase | |
| any homage to this man,� the initiators of the petition | |
| added.[/quote] | |
| The petition: | |
| www.change.org/p/ville-de-bruxelles-enlever-toutes-les-statues-e | |
| n-hommage-%C3%A0-l%C3%A9opold-ii | |
| --- | |
| And another goes down! | |
| us.yahoo.com/news/protesters-topple-confederate-statue-virginia- | |
| 054712041.html | |
| --- | |
| https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EklsmK4f-b4 | |
| --- | |
| Another: | |
| www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2020/06/08/john-b-castleman-s | |
| tatue-louisville-taken-down-cherokee-triangle/5318612002/ | |
| Also, Mayor Sadiq Khan defends the statue topplers: | |
| --- | |
| Moving beyond Confederates to colonialists proper: | |
| www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jun/09/protesters-rally-in-oxford | |
| -for-removal-of-cecil-rhodes-statue | |
| --- | |
| https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rd_0zSlX5XM | |
| --- | |
| Previously I suggested: | |
| [quote]wecould consider (as an alternative to removing entire | |
| statues) just decapitating each statue and displaying the | |
| disembodied head hanging adjacent to the rest of the statue. | |
| This would visually prove beyond anydoubt that we are not trying | |
| to make people think that the colonialists(and, by inference, | |
| the colonial era) never existed, but merely declaring what we | |
| think of colonialists.[/quote] | |
| Now: | |
| www.washingtonpost.com/history/2020/06/10/christopher-columbus-s | |
| tatue-beheaded-boston-richmond/ | |
| Thank you BLM! | |
| Also ongoing: | |
| www.yahoo.com/news/tracker-monument-statue-removal-floyd-protest | |
| s-confederate-racist-204705465.html | |
| But best of all: | |
| www.thesun.co.uk/news/11832425/second-winston-churchill-statue-v | |
| andalised-graffiti-blm-protests/ | |
| [quote]The statue of Queen Victoria was left covered in graffiti | |
| after Black Lives Matter protests in Leeds. | |
| Demonstrators sprayed the sculpture with the words �racist�, | |
| �murderer� and �slave owner�. | |
| ... | |
| Nelson's Column is another target of anti-racism campaigners who | |
| want it torn down over links to the slave trade. | |
| Campaigners want the column removed as Nelson was fiercely | |
| opposed to the abolition of the slave trade. | |
| Hesupported prominent slavers and tried to prevent the | |
| abolitionist William Wilberforce - who he dubbed 'damnable' - | |
| from ending Britain's involvement in the slave trade. | |
| Hundreds of statues could be pulled down after protesters drew | |
| up a �hitlist�. | |
| Full list of statues | |
| Francis Drake - sea captain and slave trader | |
| Drake was the first sailor to complete an entire journey of the | |
| world in one trip frm 1577 to 1580. | |
| He helped his cousin, John Hawkins, capture slaves from the | |
| Americas and sell them to Spanish plantations. | |
| William Gladstone | |
| Gladstone is a former British PM whose family owned slaves in | |
| the Caribbean. | |
| He was actively opposed to the anti-slavery movement in Britain. | |
| When slavery was banned, he helped his father obtain today's | |
| equivalent of �10.3 million in return for freeing his slaves. | |
| Horatio Nelson | |
| Aflag officer in the Royal Navy known for inspirational | |
| leadership and unconventional tactics during the Napoleonic | |
| wars. He was a supporter ofthe slave trade and actively tried to | |
| thrwart the abolitionist movementin Britain. | |
| James George Smith Neill - monument - Ayr, Wellington Square | |
| Colin Campbell, Lord Clyde � Statue - Glasgow, George Square | |
| Sir Robert Peel - Statue - Glasgow, George Square | |
| Henry Dundas � Statue - Edinburgh, St Andrew's Square | |
| Grey's Monument - Newcastle Upon Tyne, Grainger Street | |
| William Armstrong - Memorial - Newcastle Upon Tyne, Eldon Place | |
| Statue of Sir Robert Peel in George Square, Glasgow | |
| Robert Peel � Statue - Leeds, Woodhouse Moor | |
| Robert Peel � Statue - Preston, Winkley Square | |
| Robert Peel � Statue - Bury | |
| Robert Peel � Statue - Manchester, Piccadilly Gardens | |
| Oliver Cromwell � Statue - Manchester, Wythenshawe Road | |
| Oliver Cromwell � Statue - Warrington, Bridge Street | |
| Bryan Blundell - Blundell House - Liverpool, Liverpool Blue Coat | |
| School | |
| Christopher Columbus � Statue - Liverpool, Sefton Park Palm | |
| House | |
| William Leverhulme � Statue - Wirral, outside Lady Lever Art | |
| Gallery | |
| Henry Morton Stanley � Statue - Denbigh, Hall Square | |
| William Gladstone � Statue - Hawarden, Gladstone's Library, | |
| Church Lane | |
| Elihu Yale � Wetherspoons Pub - Wrexham, Regent Street | |
| Black man's head caricature - Ashbourne, Green Man | |
| Robert Clive � Statue - Shrewsbury, The Square | |
| Robert Peel � Statue - Tamworth, 27 Market Street | |
| H Morton Stanley � Park - Redditch, Morton Stanley Park | |
| Statue of Oliver Cromwell on Bridge Street, Warrington | |
| Oliver Cromwell � Statue - St Ives, Market Hill | |
| Ronald A. Fisher � Memorial - Cambridge, Gonville and Caius | |
| College | |
| Sir Thomas Picton � Memorial - Carmarthen, Picton Terrace | |
| General Nott - Statue - Carmarthen, Nott Square | |
| Thomas Phillips � Memorial plaque - Brecon, Captain's Walk | |
| Cecil Rhodes � Statue - Oxford, Oriel College | |
| Christopher Codrington � Rename Library - Oxford, Codrington | |
| Library, All Souls College | |
| Rename Rhodes Arts Complex and Rhodes Avenue - Bishop's | |
| Stortford, Cecil Rhodes | |
| Sir Thomas Picton � Statue - Cardiff, Cardiff City Hall | |
| Edward Colston � Rename Colston Hall and Colston Street - | |
| Bristol, Colston Street | |
| Henry Overton Wills III � Wills Memorial Building - Bristol, | |
| University of Bristol | |
| Edward Colston � Statue - Bristol, Bristol Harbour | |
| Edward Colston - Building - Bristol, Colston Tower, Colston | |
| Street | |
| Captain Edward August Lendy & Captain Charles Frederick Lendy� | |
| Memorial Statue - Sunbury-on-Thames, Pantiles Court | |
| Edward Colston � Rename Colston Road - Mortlake, Colston Road | |
| William Beckford � School - London, Dornfell Street | |
| Statue of Robert Clive in The Square, Shrewsbury | |
| Robert Geffrye � Statue located on the Museum of the Home - | |
| London, Kingsland Road | |
| Francis Galton � Galton Lecture Theatre - London, Gower Street | |
| Charles II of England � Statue - London, Soho Square Gardens | |
| King James II � Statue - London, Trafalgar Square | |
| Robert Clive � Statue - London, Westminster, King Charles Street | |
| Oliver Cromwell � Statue - London, Houses of Parliament | |
| Sir Robert Clayton � Statue - London, St Thomas' Hospital, | |
| Westminster Bridge Road | |
| SirHenry De la Beche � Name on front of Imperial College - | |
| London, Royal School of Mines, Imperial College London, South | |
| Kensington Campus | |
| Christopher Columbus � Monument - London, Belgrave Square Garden | |
| Thomas Guy � Statue - London, Guys Hospital | |
| Thomas Guy - London, Guy's Hospital | |
| Robert Milligan � Statue - London, Tower Hamlets, West India | |
| Quay | |
| Sir Francis Drake, Robert Blake, Horatio Nelson � Statues - | |
| London, Deptford Town Hall, Goldsmiths College | |
| Sir Francis Drake, Robert Blake and Horatio Nelson � Statues - | |
| London, Goldsmiths Uni Deptford Town Hall | |
| Statue of Sir Robert Clayton on Westminster Bridge Road, London | |
| Lord Kitchener � Statue - Chatham, Khartoum Road | |
| Admiral Sir Edward Codrington � Plaque - Brighton, Western Road | |
| William Ewart Gladstone � Plaque - Brighton, Royal Albion Hotel | |
| Christopher Barry Russell � Office - Cosham, Admiral House | |
| Redvers Buller � Statue - Exeter, Hele Road | |
| Francis Drake � Statue - Tavistock, Drakes Roundabout | |
| Nancy Astor � Statue - Plymouth, Hoe Park | |
| Francis Drake - Statue - Plymouth, Plymouth Hoe[/quote] | |
| I like leftists who are methodical about activism. | |
| Theabove list pertains to just the UK, though. We need similar | |
| lists for every country affected by Western colonialism. Anyone | |
| want to volunteer? | |
| [quote]A group called Topple the Racists want statues across | |
| Britain removed and street names changed. | |
| Theirlist includes some of Britain�s most famous historical | |
| figures including King James II, Oliver Cromwell and Christopher | |
| Columbus. | |
| Thegroup said: �We believe these statues and other memorials to | |
| slave-owners and colonialists need to be removed so that Britain | |
| can finally face the truth about its past � and how it shapes | |
| our present. | |
| ... | |
| �We must learn from, not venerate, this terrible chapter in | |
| British colonial history.�[/quote] | |
| Very well put. We support this group unreservedly: | |
| www.toppletheracists.org/ | |
| Keep up the good work! | |
| [quote]Meanwhile,it has been announced 130 Labour councils | |
| across England and Wales willbegin reviewing monuments and | |
| statues in their towns and cities. | |
| It means dozens more monuments could be removed. | |
| Astatement posted on Twitter said: "LGA Labour have consulted | |
| with all Labour council leaders, and there is overwhelming | |
| agreement from all Labour councils that they will listen to and | |
| work with their local communities to review the appropriateness | |
| of local monuments and statueson public land and council | |
| property."[/quote] | |
| I wish success to all involved. To colonialist statues | |
| everywhere: WE WILL REPLACE YOU! | |
| --- | |
| Meanwhile, more successes back in the US: | |
| www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8408251/Pelosi-demands-Republic | |
| ans-agree-remove-11-Confederate-statues-Capitol-Hill.html | |
| (pictures and information about the statues included) | |
| Also some I missed earlier: | |
| www.yahoo.com/news/jefferson-davis-statue-torn-down-034826808.ht | |
| ml | |
| www.arkansasonline.com/news/2020/jun/10/protesters-topple-columb | |
| us-statue-minnesota/ | |
| --- | |
| https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uFJvIjCkYDU | |
| #Post#: 7-------------------------------------------------- | |
| Re: Statue decolonization | |
| By: 90sRetroFan Date: June 30, 2020, 2:09 am | |
| --------------------------------------------------------- | |
| OLD CONTENT contd. | |
| Recap of earlier years: | |
| www.yahoo.com/news/pulling-down-statues-racists-africas-07010794 | |
| 4.html | |
| [quote]JOHANNESBURG(AP) � Queen Victoria, Cecil Rhodes, King | |
| Leopold. Statues honoring these leaders of colonial rule have | |
| been pulled down over the years in Africa after countries won | |
| independence or newer generations said racistrelics had to go. | |
| New campaigns in the U.S. and Europe are now following Africa�s | |
| lead. Monuments to slave traders and colonial rulers have become | |
| the focus of protests around the world, driven by a | |
| reexamination of historical injustice after the death of George | |
| Floyd atthe hands of police in the U.S. | |
| No protests have been spotted this week around the remaining | |
| statues in Africa, but several have facedfurious demonstrations | |
| in the past. | |
| A boisterous student-led campaign pressed the University of Cape | |
| Town to remove a statue of CecilRhodes from the school's | |
| entrance in April 2015. The statue had been defaced and covered | |
| in excrement by students protesting against the colonial leader | |
| who supported white minority rule in South Africa and the | |
| colonization of the southern African territories named for him, | |
| Northern and Southern Rhodesia, which later became independent | |
| Zambia and Zimbabwe. | |
| Students celebrated as a crane lifted the statue off its base. | |
| Now the statue is covered by a tarpaulin at a local army base. | |
| Anotherstatue of Rhodes was toppled in Zimbabwe in July 1980, a | |
| few months after the country became independent. When the statue | |
| was downed in the capital � then known by its colonial name, | |
| Salisbury, now Harare � demonstrators cheered and pounded it | |
| with a hammer. | |
| A statue of Britain�s Queen Victoria in Nairobi, Kenya, was | |
| knocked down and beheaded in 2015 by unknown vandals. The | |
| headless statue lies next to its plinth in a downtown square. | |
| �This statue reminds me of the suffering our forefathers went | |
| through in the hands of colonialists and whenever we see them, | |
| the memories are fresh,� Nairobi resident Samuel Obiero said. | |
| �We need to get rid of them. All over the world they must be | |
| brought down and all people who suffered due to colonialism need | |
| to also be saved from all these kinds of memories.� | |
| InCongo, a statue honoring colonial ruler King Leopold II of | |
| Belgium � a copy of the statue that is now the focus of | |
| demonstrations in Belgium � was pulled down decades ago. Erected | |
| in 1928, it was ordered taken down by then-dictator Mobutu Sese | |
| Seko seven years after independence in 1960. | |
| The statue made a return in 2005 with an updated plaque, | |
| intended by authorities to serve as a reminder of the horrors of | |
| colonial rule. Public outcry was so great that it was taken down | |
| a day later. | |
| Now it stands in a park of colonial monuments set up on the | |
| grounds of the Institute of National Museums set up by the U.N. | |
| mission in Congo. Although the park is technically open to the | |
| public, access is limited because of its proximity to the | |
| president�s residence in the capital, Kinshasa. The park also | |
| has statues of explorers Henry Morton Stanley and David | |
| Livingstone. | |
| There have been so many protests against the statue of Paul | |
| Kruger, an early white ruler of South Africa, in the capital, | |
| Pretoria, that fencing has been erected tokeep people away from | |
| it. �Killer Killer� is prominently painted on itsbase. | |
| �It just reminds me of, like, what�s written over there, �Killer | |
| Killer,�� said Rogue Wanga, a 19-year-old street vendor. "Those | |
| people were killers literally. And they never liked us. I feel | |
| like we should replace it. Maybe a fountain or a Madiba (Nelson | |
| Mandela) statue wouldn�t hurt.� | |
| ... | |
| South African author William Gumede said pulling down statues is | |
| just the first step in a process. | |
| �It'simportant for these symbols of injustice to be pulled | |
| down,� Gumede said. �This has been going on for decades, and we | |
| are grappling with ridding ourselves of these monuments to | |
| domination.�[/quote] | |
| But is there less enthusiasm about pulling down colonialist | |
| statues in former colonies in other parts of the world? If so, | |
| why? And what can bedone to increase such enthusiasm? | |
| --- | |
| Next one: | |
| www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8418521/New-Orleans-protesters- | |
| pull-bust-throw-river.html | |
| [quote]Black Lives Matter protesters rip down bust of slave | |
| owner John McDonogh in New Orleans then throw it into the | |
| Mississippi River[/quote] | |
| --- | |
| Continuing: | |
| www.oregonlive.com/news/2020/06/pioneer-statues-toppled-amid-pro | |
| tests-at-university-of-oregon.html | |
| [quote]The statues have a history tied to the celebration of | |
| white conquest, and some students had renewed calls for their | |
| removal against a backdrop of international protests against | |
| racism and police brutality. | |
| ... | |
| ThePioneer was the first statue on the University of Oregon | |
| campus, according to the university website. During the 1919 | |
| ceremony in which it was dedicated, the president of the Oregon | |
| Historical Society gave a speech lauding the �Anglo-Saxon race,� | |
| according to a Hidden History article on the university�s | |
| library website. | |
| The Pioneer Mother, erected in 1932, was the other statue | |
| removed by protesters. Researcher Brenda Frink told The | |
| Register-Guard in 2012 that similar pioneer motherstatues | |
| celebrated �the expansion of American territory and the | |
| expansion of white occupation of that land.� | |
| ... | |
| Also on the list was a renaming of Deady Hall, named after | |
| Matthew Deady, the racist judge who founded the University of | |
| Oregon law school. Deady was a notedproponent of slavery and | |
| said only �pure white� men should be allowed to vote, according | |
| to a report commissioned by university President Michael Schill | |
| in 2016.[/quote] | |
| --- | |
| [quote]activists in northern New Mexico celebrated the removal | |
| of another likeness of O�ate that was on public display at a | |
| cultural center in the community of Alcalde. Rio Arriba County | |
| officials removed it to safeguard it from possible damage and to | |
| avoid civil unrest ahead of a scheduled protest. | |
| A forklift priedthe massive bronze statue of O�ate on horseback | |
| from a concrete pedestal. Cheers erupted among bystanders who | |
| saw the memorial as an affront to indigenous people and an | |
| obstacle to greater racial harmony, though several people also | |
| arrived to defend the tribute to O�ate. | |
| ... | |
| The O�ate statues have been a source of criticism for decades. | |
| O�ate,who arrived in present-day New Mexico in 1598, is | |
| celebrated as a cultural father figure in communities along the | |
| Upper Rio Grande that trace their ancestry to Spanish settlers. | |
| But he�s also reviled for his brutality. | |
| To Native Americans, O�ate is known for having orderedthe right | |
| feet cut off of 24 captive tribal warriors that was precipitated | |
| by the killing of Onate�s nephew. In 1998, someone sawed the | |
| right foot off the statue � an incident that weighed in the | |
| decisionto stash away the statue.[/quote] | |
| --- | |
| abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory/statue-pioneer-linked-california-gol | |
| d-rush-removed-71267009 | |
| [quote]Severaldozen people cheered as a work crew lifted the | |
| statue of John Sutter � a19th century European colonizer of | |
| California who enslaved Native Americans � off its pedestal | |
| outside Sutter Medical Center in the latestreckoning of | |
| historical figures being removed from public display. | |
| ... | |
| AshwutRodriguez, a California Indian from Sacramento, spit on | |
| the statue of Sutter after it was loaded onto a flatbed and tied | |
| down. | |
| �This isonly a Band Aid on a broken arm, but we can�t celebrate | |
| or consider anything until you stop celebrating these evil | |
| people,� said Rodriguez, 42, who came out with his family and | |
| young children to watch.[/quote] | |
| www.yahoo.com/news/christopher-columbus-statue-removed-st-152227 | |
| 289.html | |
| [quote]Astatue of Christopher Columbus that stood in a St. Louis | |
| park for more than 130 years has been removed amid a growing | |
| national outcry against monuments to the 15th century explorer | |
| (June 16)[/quote] | |
| --- | |
| www.nbcnews.com/politics/congress/pelosi-orders-removal-four-por | |
| traits-confederate-house-speakers-capitol-n1231436 | |
| [quote]Pelosi requested the immediate removal of the portraits | |
| of Robert Hunter of Virginia who served as House speaker from | |
| 1839 to 1841; Howell Cobbs of Georgia (1849 to 1851); James Orr | |
| of South Carolina (1857 to 1859); and Charles Crisp of Georgia | |
| (1891 to 1895). | |
| "We cannot honor men such as James Orr, who swore on the House | |
| Floor to 'preserve and perpetuate' slavery in order to 'enjoy | |
| our property in peace, quiet and security,' or Robert Hunter, | |
| who served at nearly every level of the Confederacy, including | |
| in the Confederate Provincial Congress, as Confederate Secretary | |
| of State, in the Confederate Senate and in the Confederate | |
| Army,� Pelosi wrote in the letter. "The portraits of these men | |
| are symbols that set back our nation's work to confront and | |
| combat bigotry." | |
| ... | |
| The speaker said during her weekly press conference Thursday | |
| that she and her team were unaware that the portraits existed | |
| inside the Capitol until "we were taking inventory of the | |
| statues and the curator told us" about the four paintings of the | |
| Confederate speakers.[/quote] | |
| --- | |
| www.yahoo.com/news/north-carolina-protesters-tear-down-025419841 | |
| .html | |
| [quote]Protesters in North Carolina's capital pulled down parts | |
| of a Confederate monumentFriday on night and hanged one of the | |
| toppled statues from a light post.[/quote] | |
| Today, Western statues. Tomorrow, Western civilization. | |
| --- | |
| www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/jun/20/protesters-statue-washin | |
| gton-dc-albert-pike-juneteenth-us | |
| [quote]Cheering demonstrators jumped up and down as the 11-foot | |
| (3.4-meter) statue of Albert Pike � wrapped with chains � | |
| wobbled on its high granite pedestalbefore falling backward, | |
| landing in a pile of dust. Protesters then seta bonfire and | |
| stood around it in a circle as the statue burned, chanting, �No | |
| justice, no peace, no racist police�. | |
| ... | |
| The Pike statue has been a source of controversy over the years. | |
| The former Confederate general was also a longtime influential | |
| leader of the Freemasons, who revere Pike and who paid for the | |
| statue. Pike�s body is interred at the DC headquarters of the | |
| Scottish Rite of Freemasonry, which also contains a small museum | |
| in his honor.[/quote] | |
| --- | |
| Our enemies report: | |
| voiceofeurope.com/2020/06/foreigners-start-petitions-to-remove-r | |
| acist-scandinavian-statues/ | |
| [quote]Theiconoclasm in US and UK has now spread to Scandinavia, | |
| where petitions in Sweden and Norway have called for statues of | |
| �racist� historical persons to be taken down. | |
| ... | |
| Jallow, a foreigner, disapproves of Sweden�s commemoration of | |
| Von Linne because he was the first scientist who divided mankind | |
| into races. There are statues of him in various cities | |
| throughout Sweden. Recently, far-left activists have launched a | |
| petition to have one of Von Linne�s statues removed. At present, | |
| the petition has 1,566 signatures. | |
| Meanwhile, in Norway, a Moroccan woman living named Yasmin | |
| Zannachi has started the petition to take downtwo statues in | |
| Oslo � one of Winston Churchill, and the other of the Norwegian | |
| writer Ludvig Holberg, Document Norway reports. | |
| ... | |
| Zannachi�s petition, which now has over 4,000 signatures, is | |
| supported by the youth organization of the Norwegian Greens. | |
| TeodorBruu, spokesperson for the Norwegian Green Youth says: �We | |
| think it is totally obvious that we should not have statues of | |
| racists and slave traders in our towns.�[/quote] | |
| --- | |
| Enemy tweet: coming for, like, ulysses s grant's ass? not sure | |
| about that one. | |
| en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Native_American_policy_of_the_Ulysses_S._G | |
| rant_administration#Buffalo_destruction | |
| [quote]Centralto the Grant administration Peace policy was | |
| allowing the destruction of the buffalo, the Native food supply, | |
| to keep Native peoples dependenton government supplies. In 1872, | |
| around two thousand white buffalo hunters working between | |
| Kansas, and Arkansas were killing buffalo for their hides by the | |
| many thousands. The demand was for boots for Europeanarmies, or | |
| machine belts attached to steam engines. Acres of land were | |
| dedicated solely for drying the hides of the slaughtered | |
| buffalo.[/quote] | |
| And the double-standard to top it off: | |
| [quote]Ranchers wanted the buffalo gone to open pasture land for | |
| their cattle herds.[/quote] | |
| It is true that Grant was opposed to discrimination against | |
| "blacks": | |
| en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ulysses_S._Grant#Reconstruction_and_civil_ | |
| rights | |
| [quote]Grantwas considered an effective civil rights president, | |
| concerned about theplight of African Americans.[312] On March | |
| 18, 1869, Grant signed into law equal rights for blacks, to | |
| serve on juries and hold office, in Washington D.C., and in 1870 | |
| he signed into law the Naturalization Act that gave foreign | |
| blacks citizenship.[312] During his first term, Reconstruction | |
| took precedence. Republicans controlled most Southern states, | |
| propped up by Republican controlled Congress, northern money, | |
| and southern military occupation.[313] Grant advocated the | |
| ratification of the Fifteenth Amendment that said states could | |
| not disenfranchise African Americans.[315][/quote] | |
| but this is only further evidence that (contrary to rightist | |
| accusations ofBLM ethnotribalism) BLM cares not just about | |
| oppression of "blacks" | |
| --- | |
| Here is a start for the US. This only has Confederate monuments, | |
| but this dataset can be downloaded expanded upon to include | |
| Columbus statues, pioneer settler monuments, etc. | |
| www.splcenter.org/20190201/whose-heritage-public-symbols-confede | |
| racy#findings | |
| This page has the data in a simplified format: | |
| [quote]Across the United States, there are an estimated 1,741 | |
| public symbols of the Confederacy, according to the Southern | |
| Poverty Law Center. | |
| These symbols include schools, parks, bridges, roads, statues | |
| and more. | |
| ... | |
| In2017, during a protest against the removal of a statue of | |
| Confederate general Robert E Lee, a self-described neo-Nazi | |
| killed 32-year-old Heather Heyer after he rammed his car into a | |
| crowd of counter-protestersin Charlottesville, Virginia. | |
| Since then, at least 44 monuments have been removed across the | |
| country. | |
| The map below shows where the 771 statues and monuments are in | |
| the US:[/quote] | |
| www.aljazeera.com/indepth/interactive/2020/06/mapping-hundreds-c | |
| onfederate-statues-200610103154036.html | |
| --- | |
| We have arrived in France: | |
| www.breitbart.com/europe/2020/06/22/protesters-deface-french-col | |
| onial-era-statues-in-red-paint/ | |
| [quote]PARIS(AP) � Two Paris statues related to France�s | |
| colonial era were daubed with red paint Monday amid a global | |
| movement to take down monuments to figures tied to slavery or | |
| colonialism. | |
| One statue was of Hubert Lyautey, near the gold-domed Invalides | |
| monument that houses Napoleon�s tomb. Lyautey served in Morocco, | |
| Algeria, Madagascar and Indochina when they were under French | |
| control, and later was France�s minister of war during World War | |
| I. | |
| The other figure drenched in red shows Voltaire, a leading | |
| thinker and writer of the French Enlightenment, who owed part of | |
| his fortune to colonial-era trade.[/quote] | |
| No topplings yet, though..... | |
| --- | |
| Well spotted! | |
| www.yahoo.com/news/petition-to-change-badge-st-michael-st-george | |
| -queen-honour-104906375.html | |
| [quote]A petition is calling for one of the Queen�s highest | |
| honours to be redesigned as campaigners say it resembles a white | |
| man killing a black man. | |
| ... | |
| On the petition, Tracy Reeve wrote: �The image on the Honorary | |
| Knights/Dames Commander (KCMG/DCMG) star is a white skinned | |
| angel stood on the head/neck of a black skinned devil. | |
| �This is ahighly offensive image, it is also reminiscent of the | |
| recent murder of George Floyd by the white policeman in the same | |
| manner presented here inthis medal. | |
| �We the undersigned are calling for this medal to completely | |
| redesigned in a more appropriate way and for an official apology | |
| to be given for the offence it has given!� | |
| ... | |
| Sir Simon Woolley, the director and one of the founders of | |
| Operation Black Vote, told The Guardian: �The original image may | |
| have been of St Michael slaying Satan, but the figure has no | |
| horns or tail and is clearly a black man. It is a shocking | |
| depiction, and it is even more shocking thatthat image could be | |
| presented to ambassadors representing this country abroad. | |
| �For most black and brown people, there is nothing good about | |
| the empire. Most people will see this as an image of George | |
| Floyd on a global scale and a symbol of white | |
| supremacy.�[/quote] | |
| Judge for yourself: | |
| [img] | |
| https://s.yimg.com/ny/api/res/1.2/uAQSE6x4E1O7Btpbjjqk0g--/YXBwaWQ9aGlnaGxhbmRl… | |
| --- | |
| www.washingtontimes.com/news/2020/jun/23/andrew-cuomo-defends-de | |
| struction-us-monuments-its-/ | |
| New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo called the attacks on monuments | |
| �healthy expression� and �good statements.� | |
| [quote]In an appearance Tuesday on NBC, he denied President | |
| Trump�s admonition that, in the words of interviewer Savannah | |
| Guthrie, �cities should do more to protect monuments.� | |
| ... | |
| �People are making a statement about equality, about community, | |
| to be against racism, against slavery, Ithink those are good | |
| statements,� the Democratic governor said. | |
| ... | |
| �It�sa healthy expression of people saying let�s get some | |
| priorities here and let�s remember the sin and mistake that this | |
| nation made and let�s not celebrate it,� he said.[/quote] | |
| [img] | |
| https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/proxy/ueqrD1GgopO-i4JkhlLOuDB4_GPRhwqWTnMDsPR… | |
| #Post#: 8-------------------------------------------------- | |
| Re: Statue decolonization | |
| By: 90sRetroFan Date: June 30, 2020, 2:22 am | |
| --------------------------------------------------------- | |
| Not all statues involve people: | |
| https://nbcmontana.com/news/local/man-arrested-for-taking-down-kalispell-monume… | |
| [quote]MISSOULA, Mont. � A Columbia Falls man is behind bars | |
| after police say he took down the Ten Commandments monument in | |
| Kalispell with a chain and a pickup truck.[/quote] | |
| #Post#: 36-------------------------------------------------- | |
| Re: Statue decolonization | |
| By: 90sRetroFan Date: July 2, 2020, 1:47 am | |
| --------------------------------------------------------- | |
| https://nypost.com/2020/07/01/christopher-columbus-statue-removed-outside-colum… | |
| https://apnews.com/b27b2bfce3ecefe13c917a69a59cd9da | |
| [quote]Stonewall Jackson removed from Richmond�s Monument | |
| Avenue[/quote] | |
| https://www.yahoo.com/news/belgium-king-leopold-statue-removed-115117221.html | |
| [quote]A statue of former Belgian king Leopold II has been | |
| removed in the city of Ghent as Belgium marked the 60th | |
| anniversary of the end of its colonial rule in the Democratic | |
| Republic of Congo.[/quote] | |
| We still have a very long way to go, however: | |
| https://us.yahoo.com/news/worshipping-whiteness-why-racist-symbols-080048241.ht… | |
| #Post#: 52-------------------------------------------------- | |
| Re: Statue decolonization | |
| By: guest5 Date: July 2, 2020, 10:15 am | |
| --------------------------------------------------------- | |
| Was Mahatma Gandhi racist? | The Stream | |
| [quote]The University of Ghana has removed a statue of the | |
| Indian independence leader Mahatma Gandhi, citing complaints | |
| from faculty and students that he was racist toward black | |
| Africans. The statue was donated to the university in 2016 by | |
| the Indian government, prompting critics to create the hashtag | |
| #GandhiMustFall to draw attention to derogatory statements the | |
| young Gandhi had written while living in South Africa. | |
| Gandhi is considered an icon of social justice and defenders of | |
| his legacy contend that his writings, while ignorant, should be | |
| considered within the greater context of his life and struggle | |
| against oppression. Organisers of the hashtag campaign argue | |
| that Gandhi�s legacy doesn�t justify racism or his view that | |
| Africans were �inferior�. | |
| In this episode, we speak with Gandhi historians and | |
| #GandhiMustFall campaigners to explore the impact of Mahatma | |
| Gandhi�s reported racism on his legacy as a champion of civil | |
| rights. Join the conversation.[/quote] | |
| https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IWFQtAejmfM | |
| Mahatma Gandhi's Statue Vandalised In London Amid Black Lives | |
| Matter Protest | |
| [quote]Days after the desecration of a Mahatma Gandhi statue US | |
| capital Washington DC during George Floyd protests, protestors | |
| in Parliament Square, London, targeted a Gandhi statue on the | |
| other side of the Atlantic, spraying 'racist' on its foundation | |
| and splattering it with white paint. During the George Floyd | |
| protests in Parliament Square, which has emerged as one of the | |
| major hubs of protests in London, some miscreants took to | |
| defiling the statues located along the main square. | |
| The main square holds statues of some historically respected | |
| figures of political movement including Abraham Lincoln and | |
| Winston Churchill. Most of the statues along the main square | |
| were defiled with words such as 'racist' spray-painted on them, | |
| while some saw placards of the Black Lives Matter movement being | |
| hung around their necks.[/quote] | |
| https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gxhb-JOHV8Q | |
| #Post#: 85-------------------------------------------------- | |
| Re: Statue decolonization | |
| By: 90sRetroFan Date: July 3, 2020, 11:59 pm | |
| --------------------------------------------------------- | |
| https://twitter.com/FordFischer/status/1278795602583789573 | |
| [quote]Following yesterday's order by Richmond Mayor Levar | |
| Stoney to remove all Confederate Statues immediately, a second | |
| figure was removed. | |
| The statue of Matthew Maury, a Confederate Naval officer, was | |
| removed this morning.[/quote] | |
| https://www.marketwatch.com/story/after-confederate-statues-controversy-native-… | |
| [quote]�There�s no question Andrew Jackson was the worst | |
| president ever for Native Americans � cruel, horrible,� said | |
| Rep. Deb Haaland, a New Mexico Democrat. Haaland is one of only | |
| four Native Americans and one of two Native women in Congress. | |
| Haaland, a member of the Pueblo of Laguna in New Mexico, said | |
| Jackson�s statue doesn�t deserve its place in the | |
| Rotunda.[/quote] | |
| https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M4OVEEuXA0c | |
| Also the following is a worthwhile perspective: | |
| https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/26/opinion/confederate-monuments-racism.html | |
| [quote]You Want a Confederate Monument? My Body Is a Confederate | |
| Monument | |
| The black people I come from were owned and raped by the white | |
| people I come from. Who dares to tell me to celebrate them? | |
| ... | |
| I am a black, Southern woman, and of my immediate white male | |
| ancestors, all of them were rapists. My very existence is a | |
| relic of slavery and Jim Crow. | |
| According to the rule of hypodescent (the social and legal | |
| practice of assigning a genetically mixed-race person to the | |
| race with less social power) I am the daughter of two black | |
| people, the granddaughter of four black people, the | |
| great-granddaughter of eight black people. Go back one more | |
| generation and it gets less straightforward, and more sinister. | |
| As far as family history has always told, and as modern DNA | |
| testing has allowed me to confirm, I am the descendant of black | |
| women who were domestic servants and white men who raped their | |
| help. | |
| It is an extraordinary truth of my life that I am biologically | |
| more than half white, and yet I have no white people in my | |
| genealogy in living memory. No. Voluntary. Whiteness. I am more | |
| than half white, and none of it was consensual. White Southern | |
| men � my ancestors � took what they wanted from women they did | |
| not love, over whom they had extraordinary power, and then | |
| failed to claim their children. | |
| What is a monument but a standing memory? An artifact to make | |
| tangible the truth of the past. My body and blood are a tangible | |
| truth of the South and its past. The black people I come from | |
| were owned by the white people I come from. The white people I | |
| come from fought and died for their Lost Cause. And I ask you | |
| now, who dares to tell me to celebrate them? Who dares to ask me | |
| to accept their mounted pedestals? | |
| ... | |
| Either you have been blind to a truth that my body�s story | |
| forces you to see, or you really do mean to honor the oppressors | |
| at the expense of the oppressed, and you must at last | |
| acknowledge your emotional investment in a legacy of hate. | |
| Either way, I say the monuments of stone and metal, the | |
| monuments of cloth and wood, all the man-made monuments, must | |
| come down. I defy any sentimental Southerner to defend our | |
| ancestors to me. I am quite literally made of the reasons to | |
| strip them of their laurels.[/quote] | |
| I of course recommend the author to voluntarily refrain from | |
| reproducing so as to terminate the bloodline she carries ASAP. | |
| Though more importantly the state needs to step in and prohibit | |
| actual racists from reproducing. | |
| We need to start promoting what I am hereby coining genetic | |
| cancel culture. The physical cancel culture currently being | |
| practiced, consisting of eliminating colonialist symbols, is | |
| well-intentioned but ultimately superficial, and dangerous if we | |
| presume it is sufficient. Eliminating the bloodlines celebrated | |
| by those symbols is the only true solution. | |
| #Post#: 107-------------------------------------------------- | |
| Re: Statue decolonization | |
| By: 90sRetroFan Date: July 4, 2020, 11:40 pm | |
| --------------------------------------------------------- | |
| https://uk.news.yahoo.com/protesters-pull-down-columbus-statue-024421492.html | |
| [quote]Baltimore protesters pulled down a statue of Christopher | |
| Columbus and threw it into the city's Inner Harbor on Saturday | |
| night.[/quote] | |
| https://twitter.com/louiskraussnews/status/1279579607637917699 | |
| ***************************************************** | |
| Next Page |