 |
Return Create A Forum - Home |
 |
--------------------------------------------------------- |
|
RateTheRef |
 |
https://ratetheref.createaforum.com |
|
--------------------------------------------------------- |
|
***************************************************** |
|
Return to: Cup Appointments |
|
***************************************************** |
|
#Post#: 84389-------------------------------------------------- |
|
Re: The Emirates FA Cup - 2024/2025 |
|
By: aaa Date: October 28, 2024, 11:17 am |
|
--------------------------------------------------------- |
|
First Round Proper - No Replay |
|
Fri 1st Nov 2024 |
|
Notts County F.C. (First Team) v Alfreton Town FC (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Simpson, Scott |
|
Assistant Referee: Durnall, Steve |
|
Assistant Referee: Wigglesworth, Richard |
|
Fourth Official: Robinson, Ben |
|
Tamworth FC (First Team) v Huddersfield Town FC (First Team) |
|
Live on BBC Two & iPlayer |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Speedie, Benjamin |
|
Assistant Referee: Hetherington, Harley |
|
Assistant Referee: Khan, Abbas |
|
Fourth Official: Jackson, Scott |
|
Sat 2nd Nov 2024 |
|
Barrow AFC (First Team) v Doncaster Rovers FC (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Baines, Dale |
|
Assistant Referee: Carney, Emily |
|
Assistant Referee: Simpson, Joe |
|
Fourth Official: Claussen, Robert |
|
Brackley Town FC (First Team) v Braintree Town FC (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Morland, Stuart |
|
Assistant Referee: Wilson, Marc |
|
Assistant Referee: O'Shea, Declan |
|
Fourth Official: Hantea, Laurentiu |
|
Bradford City FC (First Team) v Aldershot Town (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Hicks, Craig |
|
Assistant Referee: Cooke, Thomas |
|
Assistant Referee: Hall, Bradley |
|
Fourth Official: Brown, Declan |
|
Bristol Rovers (First Team) v Weston super Mare AFC (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Yates, Ollie |
|
Assistant Referee: Taylor, Grant |
|
Assistant Referee: Wilding, Darren |
|
Fourth Official: Kornasiewicz, Grzegorz |
|
Burton Albion FC (First Team) v SCARBOROUGH ATHLETIC (First |
|
Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Mather, Simon |
|
Assistant Referee: Ellis, Andrew |
|
Assistant Referee: McILravey, Ryan |
|
Fourth Official: Jones, Harry |
|
Carlisle United (First Team) v Wigan Athletic FC (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Woods, Martin |
|
Assistant Referee: Clayton, Simon |
|
Assistant Referee: Aspinall, Natalie |
|
Fourth Official: Bell, Mark |
|
Chesterfield FC (First Team) v Horsham (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Coy, Martin |
|
Assistant Referee: Sowerby, Matthew |
|
Assistant Referee: Rushton, Steven |
|
Fourth Official: Bacon, Matthew |
|
Crewe Alexandra FC (First Team) v Dagenham & Redbridge FC (First |
|
Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Mulligan, John |
|
Assistant Referee: Amphlett, Marvyn |
|
Assistant Referee: Clayton, Samuel |
|
Fourth Official: Wall, Tom |
|
Exeter City FC (First Team) v Barnet FC (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Swabey, Lee |
|
Assistant Referee: Treleaven, Dean |
|
Assistant Referee: Fudge, Samuel |
|
Fourth Official: Wilson, Adam |
|
Gillingham FC (First Team) v Blackpool FC (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Brook, Carl |
|
Assistant Referee: Mathieson, Alex |
|
Assistant Referee: Bradley, Alex |
|
Fourth Official: Baines, Daniel |
|
Grimsby Town FC (First Team) v Wealdstone FC (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Westgate, James |
|
Assistant Referee: Woodward, Daniel |
|
Assistant Referee: Bickerdike, Johnathon |
|
Fourth Official: Jones, David |
|
Hednesford Town FC (First Team) v Gainsborough Trinity FC (First |
|
Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Richardson, Jason |
|
Assistant Referee: Gough, Callum |
|
Assistant Referee: Graham, Jacob |
|
Fourth Official: Clarke, Ashley |
|
Maidenhead United FC (First Team) v Crawley Town (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Parkinson, Stephen |
|
Assistant Referee: Whitaker, Ryan |
|
Assistant Referee: Bandara, Damith |
|
Fourth Official: Merchant, Adam |
|
Newport County AFC (First Team) v Peterborough United FC (First |
|
Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Martin, Stephen |
|
Assistant Referee: Cooper, Ian |
|
Assistant Referee: Jones, Matthew |
|
Fourth Official: Miles, Jacob |
|
Northampton Town FC (First Team) v Kettering Town FC (First |
|
Team) Live on BBC Two & iPlayer |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Bell, Elliot |
|
Assistant Referee: Cresswell, Alan |
|
Assistant Referee: Williams, Ryan |
|
Fourth Official: Speedie, Benjamin |
|
Port Vale FC (First Team) v Barnsley FC (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Breakspear, Charles |
|
Assistant Referee: Robinson, Daniel |
|
Assistant Referee: Burgess, Adam |
|
Fourth Official: Scholes, Matthew |
|
Reading FC (First Team) v Fleetwood Town FC (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Howard, Paul |
|
Assistant Referee: Spender, Oliver |
|
Assistant Referee: Butler, Stuart |
|
Fourth Official: Blair, Harrison |
|
Rochdale AFC (First Team) v Bromley FC (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Bannister, Aaron |
|
Assistant Referee: Nield, Jack |
|
Assistant Referee: Stonier, Paul |
|
Fourth Official: Taylor, Shaun |
|
Rotherham United FC (First Team) v Cheltenham Town (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Herczeg, Adam |
|
Assistant Referee: Brown, Conor |
|
Assistant Referee: Hughes, Kenwyn |
|
Fourth Official: Moss, Joe |
|
Rushall Olympic FC (First Team) v Accrington Stanley FC (First |
|
Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Copeland, Steven |
|
Assistant Referee: Bickle, Oliver |
|
Assistant Referee: Husband, Christopher |
|
Fourth Official: Warner, Harry |
|
Salford City FC (First Team) v Shrewsbury Town FC (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Doughty, Leigh |
|
Assistant Referee: Russell, Mark |
|
Assistant Referee: Fitch-Jackson, Carl |
|
Fourth Official: Marsden, Paul |
|
Solihull Moors FC (First Team) v Maidstone United FC (First |
|
Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Watkins, Richie |
|
Assistant Referee: Ford, Declan |
|
Assistant Referee: Plane, Steven |
|
Fourth Official: Allsopp, Jake |
|
Southend United FC (First Team) v Charlton Athletic FC (First |
|
Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Drysdale, Darren |
|
Assistant Referee: Da Costa, Anthony |
|
Assistant Referee: Chard, Michael |
|
Fourth Official: Willmore, Jack |
|
Stevenage FC (First Team) v Guiseley AFC (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Mackey, Oliver |
|
Assistant Referee: Nicholson, David |
|
Assistant Referee: Williams, Scott |
|
Fourth Official: Head, Ryan |
|
Stockport County FC (First Team) v Forest Green Rovers (First |
|
Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Tallis, Scott |
|
Assistant Referee: Harty, Thomas |
|
Assistant Referee: Forder-Hay, Jack |
|
Fourth Official: Jones, Callum |
|
Swindon Town FC (First Team) v Colchester United FC (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Jackson, Scott |
|
Assistant Referee: Carmichael, Marcus |
|
Assistant Referee: Hickman, Andrew |
|
Fourth Official: Kane, Stuart |
|
Tonbridge Angels FC (First Team) v Harborough Town FC (First |
|
Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: [s]Martin, Ross[/s] Dale, Alan |
|
Assistant Referee: Fidler, Ciaran |
|
Assistant Referee: Stokes, Joseph |
|
Fourth Official: Myatt, Christopher |
|
Tranmere Rovers FC (First Team) v Oldham Athletic FC (First |
|
Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: [s]Bourne, Declan[/s] Martin, Ross |
|
Assistant Referee: Gray, Alex |
|
Assistant Referee: Wyatt, Jonathan |
|
Fourth Official: Rogers, Darren |
|
Walsall FC (First Team) v Bolton Wanderers FC (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Ricardo, Ruebyn |
|
Assistant Referee: Staten, Thomas |
|
Assistant Referee: Morris, Kevin |
|
Fourth Official: Roberts, Jason |
|
Woking FC (First Team) v Cambridge United FC (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: O'Connor, Jamie |
|
Assistant Referee: Lister-Flynn, Paul |
|
Assistant Referee: Hutton, David |
|
Fourth Official: Hayden, Michael |
|
Worthing FC (First Team) v Morecambe FC (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Mulhall, Sam |
|
Assistant Referee: Bennett, Andy |
|
Assistant Referee: Brown, Stephen |
|
Fourth Official: Lugg, Nigel |
|
Wycombe Wanderers FC (First Team) v YORK CITY (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Reeves, Tom |
|
Assistant Referee: Maskell, Garry |
|
Assistant Referee: Sear, Karl |
|
Fourth Official: Martland, Charles |
|
Sun 3rd Nov 2024 |
|
Boreham Wood (First Team) v Leyton Orient FC (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Durkin, James |
|
Assistant Referee: Kelly, Paul |
|
Assistant Referee: Tranter, Adrian |
|
Fourth Official: Hurst, James |
|
Curzon Ashton FC (First Team) v Mansfield Town F.C. (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Parsons, Thomas |
|
Assistant Referee: Ryder, Mark |
|
Assistant Referee: Raper, Lewis |
|
Fourth Official: Dawson, Lewis |
|
Harrogate Town FC (First Team) v Wrexham FC (First Team) |
|
Live on ITVX |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Duckworth, Edward |
|
Assistant Referee: Guest, Danny |
|
Assistant Referee: Jarvis, Danny |
|
Fourth Official: Rhodes, Garreth |
|
Milton Keynes Dons FC (First Team) v AFC Wimbledon (First Team) |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Corlett, Matt |
|
Assistant Referee: Wild, Richard |
|
Assistant Referee: Cheosiaua, Ravel |
|
Fourth Official: Conn, Morgan |
|
Sutton United FC (First Team) v Birmingham City F C (First Team) |
|
Live on ITV1 & ITVX |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Atkinson, Ben |
|
Assistant Referee: Harrison, David |
|
Assistant Referee: Bartlett, Conall |
|
Fourth Official: Dale, Alan |
|
Mon 4th Nov 2024 |
|
Chesham United FC (First Team) v Lincoln City FC (First Team) |
|
Live on ITV4 & ITVX |
|
FA Cup |
|
Referee: Chilowicz, Alex |
|
Assistant Referee: Howick, Kevin |
|
Assistant Referee: Block, Jonathon |
|
Fourth Official: Singh Gill, Sunny |
|
#Post#: 84391-------------------------------------------------- |
|
Re: The Emirates FA Cup - 2024/2025 |
|
By: elbee94 Date: October 28, 2024, 11:44 am |
|
--------------------------------------------------------- |
|
TV games for Ben Speedie, Ben Atkinson, Alex Chilowicz and |
|
newbie Elliot Bell, who seems to be a regular in league one |
|
already. Otherwise a pretty standard set of appointments with |
|
SG2�s Doughty and Martin out and about. |
|
Scott Jackson does Colchester�s 1st round game for a second year |
|
in a row. I�ve not been too impressed in my two viewings of him, |
|
hopefully 3rd time lucky. |
|
#Post#: 84506-------------------------------------------------- |
|
Re: The Emirates FA Cup - 2024/2025 |
|
By: Ryanellis Date: November 2, 2024, 12:46 pm |
|
--------------------------------------------------------- |
|
The refereeing standards are at a low point. Over the past few |
|
weeks, Crewe have received inexperienced referees. This week was |
|
another one. John Mulligan. A small referee, young looking. I |
|
thought he had an alright first half, albeit didn�t have much to |
|
do. Dagenham and Redbridge were time wasting from the first |
|
minute. Second half, he was very inconsistent with fouls, and |
|
certainly pulling. Apparently you can climb all over attackers |
|
now and then the attacker gets penalised for it? According to |
|
James Durkin and now John Mulligan you can do that. He never |
|
yellow carded anyone for time wasting. The only thing he did was |
|
wave his arm. The goal that the visitors scored was a correct |
|
penalty call, however it shouldn�t have happened in the first |
|
place because he gave a foul to the visitors which certainly |
|
wasn�t. He should�ve played on because they were pulling each |
|
other!!! He added on 7 mins second half, which I praise, however |
|
they still continued to time waste and he did nothing about it. |
|
The visitors wasted about 3 mins/ 7, and he added on 40 seconds |
|
from the 7. 4/10 performance for me. |
|
#Post#: 84519-------------------------------------------------- |
|
Re: The Emirates FA Cup - 2024/2025 |
|
By: Whistleblower Date: November 2, 2024, 5:58 pm |
|
--------------------------------------------------------- |
|
I watched the TV FA Cup match Northampton v Kettering |
|
refereed by Elliot Bell, whom I confess I had not really heard |
|
of before today. I guess he must be new to the expanded National |
|
List. I don't think he did his prospects any harm by his showing |
|
on live TV this evening. I was trying to decipher his badge |
|
LCFA, from Liverpool ? |
|
#Post#: 84520-------------------------------------------------- |
|
Re: The Emirates FA Cup - 2024/2025 |
|
By: Ryanellis Date: November 2, 2024, 6:00 pm |
|
--------------------------------------------------------- |
|
[quote author=Whistleblower link=topic=6138.msg84519#msg84519 |
|
date=1730588295] |
|
I watched the TV FA Cup match Northampton v Kettering |
|
refereed by Elliot Bell, whom I confess I had not really heard |
|
of before today. I guess he must be new to the expanded National |
|
List. I don't think he did his prospects any harm by his showing |
|
on live TV this evening. I was trying to decipher his badge |
|
LCFA, from Liverpool ? |
|
[/quote] |
|
Yes, it�s Liverpool. |
|
#Post#: 84521-------------------------------------------------- |
|
Re: The Emirates FA Cup - 2024/2025 |
|
By: UmpireIan49 Date: November 2, 2024, 6:07 pm |
|
--------------------------------------------------------- |
|
I thought Elliott Bell handled the game well in point of fact. |
|
Always in control, sanctions spot on, including a tricky call |
|
for DOGSO towards the end which was given as a yellow card in |
|
the end, enough doubt in the referee�s mind there. |
|
With it being a local derby and being on the TV, the new kid on |
|
the block can be pleased with his display. |
|
#Post#: 84522-------------------------------------------------- |
|
Re: The Emirates FA Cup - 2024/2025 |
|
By: Skydank Date: November 3, 2024, 2:23 am |
|
--------------------------------------------------------- |
|
Mr Martin Newport v Peterborough |
|
Sorry not able to post link but available on bbc site, but an |
|
interesting decision for 'muscle man' and the assistant |
|
yesterday... |
|
Ball ends up in the net after a corner, nobody sure how but |
|
'goal' not given. Restart with a corner. |
|
Not something I've seen very often |
|
#Post#: 84526-------------------------------------------------- |
|
Re: The Emirates FA Cup - 2024/2025 |
|
By: nemesis Date: November 3, 2024, 6:38 am |
|
--------------------------------------------------------- |
|
[quote author=Skydank link=topic=6138.msg84522#msg84522 |
|
date=1730622217] |
|
Mr Martin Newport v Peterborough |
|
Sorry not able to post link but available on bbc site, but an |
|
interesting decision for 'muscle man' and the assistant |
|
yesterday... |
|
Ball ends up in the net after a corner, nobody sure how but |
|
'goal' not given. Restart with a corner. |
|
Not something I've seen very often |
|
[/quote] |
|
Did they take the corner too quickly whilst he was trying to |
|
sort out some of the jostling in the box ? |
|
#Post#: 84527-------------------------------------------------- |
|
Re: The Emirates FA Cup - 2024/2025 |
|
By: rustyref Date: November 3, 2024, 6:42 am |
|
--------------------------------------------------------- |
|
[quote author=Skydank link=topic=6138.msg84522#msg84522 |
|
date=1730622217] |
|
Mr Martin Newport v Peterborough |
|
Sorry not able to post link but available on bbc site, but an |
|
interesting decision for 'muscle man' and the assistant |
|
yesterday... |
|
Ball ends up in the net after a corner, nobody sure how but |
|
'goal' not given. Restart with a corner. |
|
Not something I've seen very often |
|
[/quote] |
|
Here from 00:55. |
|
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/live/c1e7z8pj818t |
|
No idea how it ended up in the goal, but the defender certainly |
|
seems to head it against the outside of the side netting. The |
|
video doesn't show it, but I would assume the referee found a |
|
hole in the net. |
|
#Post#: 84530-------------------------------------------------- |
|
Re: The Emirates FA Cup - 2024/2025 |
|
By: Acme Thunderer Date: November 3, 2024, 7:52 am |
|
--------------------------------------------------------- |
|
[quote author=rustyref link=topic=6138.msg84527#msg84527 |
|
date=1730637720] |
|
[quote author=Skydank link=topic=6138.msg84522#msg84522 |
|
date=1730622217] |
|
Mr Martin Newport v Peterborough |
|
Sorry not able to post link but available on bbc site, but an |
|
interesting decision for 'muscle man' and the assistant |
|
yesterday... |
|
Ball ends up in the net after a corner, nobody sure how but |
|
'goal' not given. Restart with a corner. |
|
Not something I've seen very often |
|
[/quote |
|
Here from 00:55. |
|
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/live/c1e7z8pj818t |
|
No idea how it ended up in the goal, but the defender certainly |
|
seems to head it against the outside of the side netting. The |
|
video doesn't show it, but I would assume the referee found a |
|
hole in the net. |
|
[/quote] |
|
How strange. Took me back to Palace v Nottingham Forest in |
|
August 1971 when Steve Kember put the ball in the net (or so he |
|
thought) and, after protests from the Forest players, the |
|
referee, Ron Judson, found a hole in the net. Ron then enquired |
|
of the players what they thought had happened, with differing |
|
and predictable results, and he even asked the photographers |
|
behind the goal whether they could help, but all to no avail. No |
|
TV cameras to look at, despite it being a Division 1 match, and |
|
Ron ended up awarding a corner, which it definitely wasn't. The |
|
game ended 1 1 and, at the season end, Forest went down and |
|
Palace survived just. |
|
Talking of cameras, is it possible that Mr Martin got help from |
|
the 4O accessing camera footage of the incident at Newport? Just |
|
wondering. |
|
***************************************************** |
|
Previous Page |
|
Next Page |
