CURRENT_MEETING_REPORT_
Reported by Mark Knopper/Merit Network
Minutes of the Extensions to OSI for use in the Internet BOF (OSIEXTND)
The group's discussion was based on information presentation by Dave
Katz.
Editor's Note: The text of Dave Katz's presentation slides is available
via FTP or mail server from the remote directories as
/ietf/93jul/osiextnd-minutes-93jul.txt. Refer to Section 1.2 of the
proceedings for retrieval instructions.
The group agreed that a letter should be written to ISO, based on the
presentation and discussion, stating that the IETF has sufficient
expertise to contribute to these areas. Dave Katz and Dave Piscitello
will draft a document.
This work spans about six IETF working groups.
BGP and IPIDRP Working Groups are meeting jointly (IDRP is BGP5). IDRP
for SIP is being considered.
Phill Gross expressed concern over the apparent danger of having
different IETF and ISO standards for protocols. ISO has more precedence
for accepting standards from other groups without change. IETF tends to
change or rewrite protocols before acceptance. Peter Furniss said that
the Internet-Draft process will be appreciated by ISO.
Mark Knopper has created a discussion list,
[email protected]. Those
interested in being added to the list should send a request to
[email protected].
Phill Gross suggested to identify work that could be done by existing
IETF working groups, as well as that which could be done by this group
if it is to become a working group.
CLNP over Large Public Data Networks (LPDN) is an area which needs
consideration. Much of the work is done. ES-IS and IS-IS protocols
over LPDNs needs further work. Note that as of this IETF, the IPLPDN
Working Group has ended their work. Perhaps CLNPLPDN could be handled
as a BOF with identified base documents.
The consensus of the BOF attendees was that a working group should be
formed from these ideas, and relationships should be pursued with ISO.
Dave Piscitello and Dave Katz have drafted a letter and will send it to
the IESG, IAB, and ISO (through Jack Houldsworth).
Editor's Note: A copy of the letter to the IESG and IAB is available
via FTP or mail server from the remote directories as
/ietf/93jul/osiextnd-minutes-93jul.txt. Refer to Section 1.2 of the
proceedings for retrieval instructions.
Attendees
Nick Alfano
[email protected]
Bernt Allonen
[email protected]
Rebecca Bostwick
[email protected]
Jim Bound
[email protected]
Ross Callon
[email protected]
George Chang
[email protected]
A. Lyman Chapin
[email protected]
Richard Colella
[email protected]
Dave Cullerot
[email protected]
Toerless Eckert
[email protected]
Dino Farinacci
[email protected]
Peter Ford
[email protected]
Peter Furniss
[email protected]
Phillip Gross
[email protected]
Chris Gunner
[email protected]
Susan Hares
[email protected]
Denise Heagerty
[email protected]
Jack Houldsworth
[email protected]
Chris Howard
[email protected]
Geoff Huston
[email protected]
David Jacobson
[email protected]
Philip Jones
[email protected]
Cyndi Jung
[email protected]
Anders Karlsson
[email protected]
Dave Katz
[email protected]
Sean Kennedy
[email protected]
Mark Knopper
[email protected]
Rajeev Kochhar
[email protected]
Ton Koelman
[email protected]
John Krawczyk
[email protected]
Robin Littlefield
[email protected]
David Marlow
[email protected]
David O'Leary
[email protected]
Christian Panigl
[email protected]
Alex Reijnierse
[email protected]
Victor Reijs
[email protected]
Georg Richter
[email protected]
John Scudder
[email protected]
Keith Sklower
[email protected]
John Stewart
[email protected]
Kamlesh Tewani
[email protected]
Richard Thomas
[email protected]
Marcel Wiget
[email protected]
Douglas Williams
[email protected]
Rachel Willmer
[email protected]
