Subj : Re: C++ standard version in GoldEd
To : Nil Alexandrov
From : Vitaliy Aksyonov
Date : Wed Sep 27 2023 05:17 pm
�ਢ��, Nil!
27 Sep 23 14:28, �� ��ᠫ(�) Kai Richter:
NA> Tuesday September 26 2023 23:22, from Kai Richter -> Vitaliy Aksyonov
VA>>> My question is which C++ stnadard version may be appropriate in
VA>>> GoldEd?
NA> I read your question as -- what is the minimum -std=c++... I can
NA> enable in my compiler that will not break any existing or future
NA> builds. And the answer is GoldEd+ "supported" platforms and compilers.
NA> Have you seen the list? Have you seen that (semi) automated CI/CD
NA> pipeline?
NA> I am joking here but you will see that there are volunteers who are
NA> going to produce binary packages out of master branch once your pull
NA> request is merged. This will give you a clue on which platforms are
NA> still alive and what compilers they use.
NA> Optimistically, I would establish the minimum C++ standard for GoldEd+
NA> to be C++11. Though, I am not sure about Open Watcom C/C++
NA> capabilities as I have seen it in use at least for the Husky project.
Yep. I was the author of the question. Right now I'm using gcc with -std=c++98 and it compiles with my changes. But I didn't add anything fancy yet. I may try to setup Watcom compiler and try to build it there. I have tried to build with VC 2005 under Windows XP, but I need to finish dev env setup first. I've been using it long time ago and forgot a lot of stuff already. :)
KR>> Well, i'm not qualified to answer that question.
NA> At least, you can do your best effort.
That's what I'm doing. I only can't have all possible OS/compilers combinations.
VA>>> If it's possible to start using C++11, code may be made much
VA>>> safer with modern features
KR>> From a user point of view i don't care much about modern or old
KR>> code as long it is working code.
NA> As a user, will you run DOS version of GoldEd+?
KR>> From a fidonet member point of view i would like to see support
KR>> for as many as possible hard- and software platforms.
NA> Software platforms? saas software as a service?
KR>> On the other hand old code running on old hard- and software will
KR>> continue to work on old systems like they do now.
NA> True. You still can download .exe files for Dos/OS2/Win32/you name it
NA> and it shall/shouldbe compatible with the modern FTN software, because
NA> we have established FTSC facility.
Older versions can be easily build with older compliers, but would be really nice to be able to build new fixes and/or features with old compilers too.
