.-') _ .-') _ | |
( OO ) ) ( OO ) ) | |
.-----. ,--./ ,--,' ,--./ ,--,' | |
' .--./ | \ | |\ | \ | |\ | |
| |('-. | \| | )| \| | ) | |
/_) |OO )| . |/ | . |/ | |
|| |`-'| | |\ | | |\ | | |
(_' '--'\ | | \ | | | \ | | |
`-----' `--' `--' `--' `--' | |
lite.cnn.com - on gopher - inofficial | |
ARTICLE VIEW: | |
Kirk’s assassination is forcing politicians to make difficult choices | |
about their safety | |
By Michael Williams, CNN | |
Updated: | |
4:00 AM EDT, Sun September 14, 2025 | |
Source: CNN | |
The is forcing political figures and the people who protect them to | |
make agonizing choices, balancing whether the public’s access to them | |
is worth the risk in this dangerous national moment. | |
Since Kirk’s assassination, several campaigns or political groups | |
have already called off events out of an abundance of caution. And as | |
the midterm elections approach, candidates will increasingly be forced | |
to weigh their need to connect with constituents and potential voters | |
against the reality of practicing politics at a time of accelerating | |
threats, attempts and slayings. | |
“The arena they just stepped into, those threats — everything — | |
is on the table,” said Rob Savage, a former special agent in charge | |
of the US Secret Service’s Los Angeles Field Office. “Because | |
it’s just become that politically charged.” | |
Kirk’s shooting on Wednesday by a gunman at an outdoor event at Utah | |
Valley University — similar to the on Donald Trump last year at an | |
outdoor campaign rally in Butler, Pennsylvania — will likely prompt | |
organizers to move their events indoors as an immediate reaction. But | |
security experts told CNN that threats can manifest anywhere, and | |
solutions aren’t as easy as simply moving inside, stationing | |
personnel on rooftops or deploying drones. | |
Caleb Gilbert, the owner of an executive protection company whose | |
clients have included tech moguls, A-listers and ultra-high-net-worth | |
families, said Kirk’s death served as a “a deeply penetrating | |
illustration of the frailty of at-risk individuals when a dedicated | |
adversary wants to do harm.” | |
“At the end of the day, we can have guards, guns, gates, intelligence | |
— we can have everything across the board stacked just right, and we | |
can get it right 20 locations a week for years on end — and the bad | |
actors only have to get it right once,” he said. | |
A sharp increase in threats | |
Recent assassinations or attempts have taken place at political | |
rallies, but also at , , and . And threats aren’t just confined to | |
major national political figures or candidates — they have also been | |
extended toward people who have fewer resources, including state and | |
local officials, school board members, judges, political influencers | |
and all their families. | |
Princeton University’s Bridging Divides Initiative, which tracks | |
political violence in the United States, has recorded instances of | |
threats and harassment against local officials this year, an increase | |
of 9% over last year. Similar trends are emerging for state and | |
federal officials as well as judges. | |
Matt Gorman, a former communications director for House Republicans’ | |
campaign arm, said the threat of political violence is a “persistent | |
and scary reality” for lawmakers, and House members had already in | |
security funding following a deadly June attack on Minnesota state | |
lawmakers. The fear among current or potential elected officials is | |
“totally justified,” said Amanda Litman, the president of Run for | |
Something, which urges young Democrats to seek public office. | |
For those making threats, she said, “that fear is the point.” | |
In the days following Kirk’s killing, several state officials have | |
reported receiving bomb threats, as have historically Black colleges | |
and other universities across the country, as well as the Democratic | |
National Committee office in Washington. | |
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, a New York Democrat, and Sen. Ruben | |
Gallego, an Arizona Democrat, both canceled events this weekend out of | |
an abundance of caution, their campaigns said. Ben Shapiro, a | |
conservative commentator, postponed a book signing scheduled to take | |
place at the Ronald Reagan Presidential Library in California hours | |
after the shooting. Young America’s Foundation, which works with | |
young conservatives, also canceled a Thursday event in Santa Barbara | |
with Shapiro. | |
Some of the most important work for security teams that protect | |
contentious public figures happens before their clients appear at | |
events — analyzing threats they have received, triaging their degree | |
of severity and investigating whether the person who made those threats | |
has the capacity to carry them out, or lives near the event location. | |
Political assassins almost always reveal signs of their intentions to | |
friends, families or in online communities before they carry them out. | |
They “tend to leak their intentions to those around them,” but | |
people listening “invariably think, ‘Oh, he’s just mouthing | |
off,’ when in fact, they’re actually being very serious about | |
wanting to target their adversaries,” said Joshua Sinai, a professor | |
of practice, intelligence and global security studies at Capitol | |
Technology University. | |
That’s why initiatives like “See something, say something” are so | |
critical, even though they may seem cliché. The suspect in Kirk’s | |
killing, 22-year-old Tyler Robinson, was caught after a manhunt that | |
stretched more than a day after his father recognized him in pictures | |
released by the FBI. The father contacted a family friend, who then | |
contacted authorities. | |
Using drones and spotters to find snipers | |
Kirk’s killing is likely to draw some of the same scrutiny about | |
elevated positions lying outside of secured perimeters as the | |
near-successful attempt on Trump in Butler. Gilbert said his company is | |
likely to deploy discreet counter-sniper spotters at his client’s | |
outdoor events. These teams are trained to scan rooftops for threats, | |
even if they don’t have the ability to lethally respond. | |
“You have the tactical advantage if you’re able to identify anybody | |
that is out of line for that environment,” Gilbert said. “All we | |
have to identify is someone who is an anomaly for that crowd, then we | |
can send our uniformed assets over to follow up, shake their hand and | |
see what’s going on.” | |
Gilbert said he has been using other tools, like drones, for years to | |
identify threats at outdoor events. But they are not a foolproof | |
solution and should be viewed as part of a larger plan. | |
“Every outdoor event is unique and requires a professional protective | |
advance to identify and mitigate threats,” said Kevin Dye, a retired | |
Secret Service supervisor and executive protection professional. | |
“While drones have received significant attention lately, they | |
require integration into a complete security plan. Even if there were | |
drones, it would require a comprehensive communications plan to ensure | |
timely notifications of any threat.” | |
Security teams must confront a constantly evolving array of threats | |
that their clients face. Protection professionals have also had to | |
contend for bombings, arsons, car rammings, cyberattacks and any number | |
of ways their clients can be harmed up close. Long-range attacks, like | |
the ones against Kirk and Trump, are the resurgence of a phenomenon | |
that had been rarely seen since a series of sniper attacks that killed | |
American political figures in the 1960s. Several experts said they see | |
parallels between that era and this one. | |
“The only saving grace is that it’s harder to get your hands on | |
explosives now,” said Scott Stewart, the vice president of protective | |
intelligence at TorchStone Global and former special agent with the US | |
State Department’s Diplomatic Security Service. “But obviously the | |
guns are still out there, and we’re just going to continue to, I | |
fear, see this polarization and these sorts of politically motivated | |
attacks, until we do have something that causes us to pull together | |
again as a country.” | |
<- back to index |