Subj : SEEN-BY
To   : Paul Hayton
From : Andrew Leary
Date : Mon Apr 01 2019 05:26 am

Hello Paul!

01 Apr 19 12:15, you wrote to all:

PH> Mark is saying that Mystic SEEN-BY lines may be incorrect in that at
PH> the start of each line he says there should be a reference to the NET
PH> like this example he gave.

PH> When James is back on deck I was going to feed this info back to him
PH> but wanted to do due diligence first and find FTSC docs that explain
PH> this requirement.

PH> At the moment I can't find anything except in FTS-0004 where there's a
PH> section about SEEN-BY but no mention of the need to start each line
PH> with a NET/NODE combo.

PH> Can someone point me to where I can reference this need and provide
PH> any commentary about this subject please?

http://ftsc.org/docs/fsc-0074.001 has this to say:

 3. Seen-by Lines

 Seen-by lines are the focus of EchoMail distribution control
 information.  They are used to determine which addresses
 (systems) have received messages.  There can be as many seen-
 by lines as required to store the necessary information.

 Seen-by lines consist of "SEEN-BY:<space>", followed by a list
 of net/node numbers corresponding to the systems which have
 received that message.  The net/node number of each system to
 which a message is exported is added to the seen-by lines at
 the time of export.

 There shall be exactly one set of seen-by lines in a message.
 Seen-by lines:

   -  Shall follow the origin line.

   -  Shall begin with the nine character literal: _

           SEEN-BY:<space>

   -  Shall contain a list of net/node numbers.

   -  Shall be no more than 80 characters long including the
      required literal.

 The complete lines might look like:

           SEEN-BY: 104/1 501 132/101 113 136/601 1014/1
           SEEN-BY: 1014/2 3

 The list of net/node numbers:

   -  Shall identify at least one address. "Blank" seen-by
      lines shall not be transmitted.

   -  Shall be sorted in ascending net/node order.

   -  Shall not contain repeated node numbers.

   -  Shall use only "2D" net/node notation.

   -  May use short form address notation where a net number is
      listed once on any one line.  These 2 lines are
      equivalent:

           SEEN-BY: 104/1 104/501 132/101 132/113 136/601
           SEEN-BY: 104/1 501 132/101 113 136/601

 Some implementations insert a Ctrl-A (0x01) immediately
 preceding the SEEN-BY: literal (^ASEEN-BY:).

 Six months after adoption of this document the ^ASEEN-BY:
 format shall be processed equally with the SEEN-BY: format
 when either occurs in received packets.
_

The critical phrase is:  "May use short form address notation where a net
number is listed once on any one line."

My interpretation is that the net number must be listed at least once on any
one SEEN-BY line.

Regards,

Andrew

--- GoldED+/LNX 1.1.5-b20180707
* Origin: Phoenix BBS * phoenix.bnbbbs.net (1:320/219)